A/HRC/17/33/Add.3
work, none covers so-called “blue collars”, such as factory or construction workers. There
is no general resident permit that allows the permit-holder to work in any field. As a
consequence, migrants have practically no possibility of working legally as “blue collars”,
except if they obtain residence permits by virtue of their status as migrants of Japanese
descent, spouses of Japanese citizens, trainees or technical interns. Therefore, many
migrants working in factories or the construction sector are irregular.
47.
Japan does not regularize irregular migrants after a certain period of residence in the
country: many have lived in Japan for several years, sometimes for more than 15 or 20
years, and have founded a family with children born and educated in Japan. They live in
permanent fear of deportation, which affects their entire family. Following a report on
crime published by the Government in 2003 that pointed to irregular migration as one of the
causes of the increase in crimes,13 and with the economic stagnation, the Government has
tightened the control over irregular migrants in the last few years. As a consequence, they
are increasingly stopped, arrested and deported.
48.
The only possibility for migrants to acquire a regular status is the “special
permission to stay”. According to the statistics provided by the Ministry of Justice, while
39,382 persons were subject to deportation procedures in 2008, 8,522 were granted special
permission to stay. The majority of the latter were irregular migrants married to a Japanese
citizen. This permission is granted by the Ministry of Justice based on discretionary criteria
that are not set out in the law. A request for special permission to stay can only be filed
during the deportation procedure: when a deportation decision has been taken, the person
can object to it and on that basis the Ministry of Justice may grant special permission to
stay. It is of concern to the Special Rapporteur that this process seems to lack transparency
and there are no legal avenues for irregular migrant workers to regularize their status on the
basis of their employment.
G.
Detention of irregular migrant workers and asylum-seekers
49.
According to the Immigration Control Act, detention in Immigration Bureau’s
detention facilities is the rule for irregular migrants and asylum-seekers without valid
documents or legal status, although, owing to limitation of space, a number of irregular
migrants are provisionally released. However, a considerable number of irregular migrants
and asylum-seekers are detained for very long periods with limited access to judicial
processes. While a legal counsel is allowed to intervene in the procedures of requesting a
special permission to stay, such interventions are restricted. Once the permission is denied,
the person is detained awaiting deportation.
50.
Another concern relates to the fact that there is no time limit for detention, and if the
Government cannot deport the person for any reason, it can keep the person detained
indefinitely. The Special Rapporteur met irregular migrants and asylum-seekers who had
been detained in the East Japan Immigration Centre for around two years. They were in
deplorable psychological conditions, detained for a prolonged period of time without
having been tried for or convicted of any crime and without knowing whether or when they
would be released. As stated by the Committee against Torture in its concluding
observations to Japan in 2007 (CAT/C/JPN/CO/1), indefinite detention of migrants or
asylum-seekers is contrary to article 3 of the Convention against Torture and Other Cruel,
Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, and Japan should establish limits to the
length of the detention period for persons awaiting deportation.
13
12
Ibid.