A/HRC/34/56/Add.1
In the north
54.
The Special Rapporteur received extensive documentation and testimonies about
churches, monasteries, cemeteries and archaeological sites that continue to deteriorate. She
visited the Agia Marina church, a small Orthodox church situated in Yialousa/Yeni
Erenköy. The church, reportedly like many others in the north, is in a very bad state, with a
fragile structure. Once looted, it is now full of rubbish and pigeon droppings and left
neglected.
55.
The Special Rapporteur also heard concerns expressed by Armenian representatives
about, in particular, the state of the Sourp Magar (Magavarank) monastery, dating from the
tenth century, which has been left to deteriorate. Some keystones and roof tiles of the
building have allegedly been removed intentionally to cause and accelerate the collapse of
the building. Concerns were also expressed about, inter alia, the Armenian church in
Famagusta/Gazimağusa, which the community cannot access to and take care of, as well as
the convent in the Arabahmet church complex, which has not been restored and is home to
hundreds of pigeons (although its structure is physically supported to prevent collapse).
56.
Many stakeholders expressed concern about the inappropriate use of a number of
churches, in particular Orthodox churches, turned, for example, into barns. Such uses not
only accelerate the deterioration of the buildings, but are also particularly inappropriate for
venues considered sacred by others. The Armenian community also regrets that the
Armenian Evangelical church in Nicosia was turned into a bank and then a music school
and that two schools of the Arabahmet church complex have been turned into universities,
with no mention of their original use. The Special Rapporteur also notes the comments
made by cultural heritage professionals and some members of religious groups that in some
cases respectful use is, in fact, important in maintaining the buildings.
57.
The Special Rapporteur is encouraged by the fact that she also met people in the
north, from all backgrounds, who care deeply for cultural heritage, including that of others
and of those who had left, for example in the walled city of Famagusta/Gazimağusa.
2.
Enhancing the human rights approach to cultural heritage
58.
A human rights approach to cultural heritage focuses on the relationships between
people and heritage, as well as on the prevention of destruction, education about the
importance of the heritage of all and full support for cultural heritage defenders.
(a)
The restoration programme as a path toward reconciliation
59.
The 2008 agreement between Greek Cypriots and Turkish Cypriots under the
auspices of the United Nations paved the way for the establishment of the Technical
Committee on Cultural Heritage. The Committee works to provide a mutually acceptable
mechanism for the proper preservation, physical protection and restoration of the diverse
immovable cultural heritage of Cyprus. It promotes and applies a holistic and bicommunal
approach when selecting the monuments to be protected. In doing so, it complements the
regular work conducted by the authorities.
60.
The Special Rapporteur welcomes such an initiative, which is necessary to pave the
way to reconciliation. She salutes the work undertaken so far with the support of the
European Union and UNDP. She further appreciates that the mandate of the Technical
Committee includes the development of respect for cultural heritage through educational
programmes. That is crucial, as the younger generations have not experienced past social
interactions, are used to the status quo and are reportedly exposed to narratives of mistrust
of others, including through the educational system.
61.
Cultural heritage professionals, including the Technical Committee on Cultural
Heritage, need full political and financial support to complete their work. The Special
Rapporteur was concerned that one Greek Cypriot member of this Technical Committee
had reportedly been labelled a Turk in a political cartoon in the media because of his work.
Similarly, a Turkish Cypriot member said he had been called a Greek.
11