A/73/178/Rev.1
they turn to other migrants or their families for help. As recruitment agencies are often
involved in trafficking and exploitation, victims believe that the agencies are acting
with impunity owing to corruption. 54 In addition, many recruitment agencies operate
from a third country in order to circumvent the labour courts of the country in which
migrants are working. 55 Thus, victims of trafficking rarely turn to the justice system
or prefer to accept lower amounts of compensation. 56
54. There are also many institutional barriers. While establishing that a person has
been victimized is the first step towards gaining access to justice, it proves difficult
to do so, owing to the authorities’ lack of specialized knowledge and awareness, a
lack of awareness on the part of the general public, and the shortcomings of the
institutions and services responsible for providing assistance. As a result, many
victims of trafficking are treated as undocumented migrants and deported. The lack
of information and knowledge (concerning the legal consequences of being
recognized as victims, for example) on the part of victims and authorities, the lack of
accessible legal assistance (in rural and remote areas, for instance), and the duration
and cost of criminal proceedings are additional barriers that hinder migrants who are
victims of trafficking from gaining access to justice. 57 In West and Central Africa, one
of the main challenges rescued victims face is the absence of a safe location and
environment for them while receiving legal assistance. 58
55. In addition, obtaining compensation is a major challenge. It is generally easier
to obtain compensation in the labour courts than it is to obtain it in the criminal courts
for trafficking offences. Labour litigation is speedier, the labour courts authorize
direct payment of compensation to migrants and punishment of those responsible,
while the definition of exploitation is broader (for example, there is no obligation to
prove intent). However, in many cases the amounts available are completely
inadequate considering the harm caused, contrar y to what is stipulated in
anti-trafficking laws, which also allow for compensation for non -material damage. 59
56. Very few victims of trafficking have obtained compensation in criminal
proceedings owing to the difficulties of investigating transnational cases and the
insufficient support provided to victims throughout the process. 60 Embassies’ slow
pace of work and their failure to undertake effective follow-up of the proceedings,
even when a favourable judgment has been handed down, also hinder effective access
to justice and redress for migrants returning to their countries of origin. 61
57. According to some studies, a real possibility of regularization of residence
status, the provision of individualized support services, a genuine chance of receiving
compensation and access to and participation in criminal proceedings are the factors
that would enable migrants to escape abuse and exploitation and afford them access
to justice. In any event, States should not require migrants who are victims of
trafficking to cooperate with the justice system in order to receive assistance. 62
__________________
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
14/20
Submission
Submission
Submission
Ibid.
Submission
Submission
Submission
Submission
Submission
by Global Alliance Against Traffic in Women.
by the International Organization for Migration (IOM).
by Global Alliance Against Traffic in Women.
by
by
by
by
by
IOM.
Global Alliance Against Traffic in Women.
IOM.
Migrant Forum Asia.
the European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights.
18-15902