A/HRC/EMRIP/2019/2
the Gambela peoples. 25 Biofuel plantation expansion is estimated to displace some 60
million indigenous peoples in Asia. 26
26.
When it comes to development projects on indigenous peoples’ land, some of the
most challenging aspects relate to inadequate procedures and/or legislation to obtain their
free, prior and informed consent, to provide appropriate compensation and to ensure
benefit-sharing (see A/HRC/39/62). Sometimes actions contesting projects are successful,
as in 2016, when Panama withdrew the Barro Blanco hydroelectric project following
human rights complaints under the Clean Development Mechanism 27 with allegations of
displacement and impacts on the traditional lands and cultural sites of the Ngäbe peoples
(see A/HRC/36/46).
27.
The extractive industries play a large part in alienating lands and limiting access to
traditional territories (see A/HRC/24/41/Add.3). They may also affect the ecosystem and
environment through flooding, toxic pollution, contaminating water sources and weakening
flora and fauna that indigenous peoples eat or use for medicine. 28 There is evidence in Asia
of the extractive industry having changed the livelihood of indigenous peoples in whole
regions. In North Africa, the Amazigh have been pushed off their traditional lands because
of land grabbing and exploitation of natural resources. 29 The gas pipeline running from the
Bay of Bengal in Rakhine State is reported to have contributed to the displacement of the
Rohingyas.30
28.
The building of dams has also led to internal displacement and cross-border
migration. The Sardar Sarovar Dam over the Narmada River in India, inaugurated in 2017
despite strong protests, resulted in at least 200,000 people being displaced: around 57.6 per
cent of those were Adivasi peoples.31 In Borneo, 10,000 indigenous persons were displaced
in 2011 by the Bakun Dam, which flooded 700 km2 of land.32 Following the collapse of a
dam in the Lao People’s Democratic Republic in July 2018, 6,000 indigenous people were
affected. The Mursi and Bodi riparian peoples, living in the Omo valley in Ethiopia, were
considered to be the most threatened of the 200,000 peoples by dam development on the
river.33 In Brazil, mining waste threatens the life of indigenous communities.34
29.
Development projects are often accompanied by violence, unrest and political and
social turmoil, leading to migration. An increase in violence and threats against indigenous
peoples, while protecting their land, has resulted in migration. In the Philippines, the
Higaonon were removed by force from their lands for palm oil cultivation (see
A/HRC/24/41/Add.4, paras. 135–137).
3.
Conservation and tourism development
30.
Indigenous peoples, including those with legally registered traditional lands, are
often displaced because of policies designed to promote conservation and the creation of
national parks.35 In the Democratic Republic of the Congo, the Batwa of Kahuzi-Biega in
South Kivu were brutally evicted without compensation in the 1970s, after which it became
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
8
Elliot Fratkin, “Ethiopia’s pastoralist policies: development, displacement and resettlement”,
Nomadic Peoples, vol. 18, No. 1 (2014).
Asia Indigenous Peoples Pact, “Overview of the State of Indigenous Peoples in Asia” (2014).
Under the Mechanism, emission-reduction projects in developing countries can earn emission
reduction credits.
Documentation and Information Network for Indigenous Peoples’ Sustainability submission.
Congrès Mondial Amazigh submission.
Expert Mechanism seminar, Chiang Mai, Thailand, November 2018 (see para. 2).
Asia Indigenous Peoples Pact submission.
Ibid.
Fratkin, “Ethiopia’s pastoralist policies”.
www.vice.com/en_us/article/jpn84x/how-a-mining-disaster-devastated-an-indigenous-group-in-brazil
and www.reuters.com/article/us-vale-sa-disaster-indigenous/indigenous-village-faces-existentialthreat-from-brazil-dam-burst-idUSKCN1PO002.
International Institute for Environment and Development, Harry Jonas, Jael Makagon and Dilys Roe,
discussion paper, “Conservation standards: from rights to responsibilities” (2016), available at
http://pubs.iied.ord/14666IIED.