E/CN.4/1995/91
page 69
(a)
Anwar Masih, a Christian, married and father of three
children, was arrested on 2 February 1993 in Sammundri, Faisalabad
(Punjab province) following a complaint made against him by Haji Mohammad
Tayyab, the local head of Anjuman Siphal-e Sahaba (ASS). According to
the complainant, Anwar Masih is reported to have shouted angrily,
insulting Muslims and blaspheming. Mass demonstrations in Sammundri
demanded that Masih should be tried by a so-called ’special court for
speedy trial’ and publicly hanged. In addition, the day after his arrest
under section 295 C of the Penal Code, strikes are reported to have taken
place in protest against him. The complainant is said to have stated
that, on 1 February 1993, Masih made blasphemous remarks during an
argument with Mohammad Aslam, a tradesman. The latter is reported not to
have made any complaint, apparently not seeing any reason to do so in
view of his friendly relations with Masih. Aslam is said to have simply
reported the incident to members of ASS, including Tayyab, who decided to
make a complaint. Anwar Masih, who was born into a Christian family, is
said to have converted to Islam twice and then to have reverted to the
Christian faith. According to some information, Masih was a drug addict
and was considered mentally unstable by the members of his community.
According to some testimonies, Aslam and Masih both insulted each other’s
religion during their argument. However, under the blasphemy laws, only
alleged attacks on Islam may be the subject of complaint. The
Special Rapporteur was also informed that Masih was associated with local
protests which related to the indication of an individual’s religion on
his national identity card and which reportedly displeased ASS.
Anwar Masih is said to have rejected the charges of blasphemy and
explained that he had simply had an argument over debts. Masih, who was
initially detained at Sammundri prison, was reportedly transferred to
Faisalabad prison. ASS members continued to organize protest
demonstrations in Sammundri during the month of February. They also
threatened to burn down the Christian areas of Sammundri (inhabited by
some 20,000 Christians) unless Masih was publicly hanged. Proceedings
are reported to be still under way.
(b)
Sorvar Bhatti (case mentioned in the communication of
8 November 1993 is said to have been released from prison in early 1994
after having been cleared of charges of blasphemy. According to some
information, however, Sorvar Bhatti was forced into hiding following
death threats by complainants.
(c)
Chand Barkat, a 30-year-old Christian, was arrested on
8 October 1991 for blasphemy and is reported to have been acquitted in
January 1993. Six Muslim witnesses reportedly admitted in court that
they had not heard Barkat blaspheme. None the less, since his release on
24 January 1994, Barkat and his family are said to have repeatedly been
the victims of harassment and intimidation by their Muslim neighbours.
In addition, local Muslim clergymen are said to have made death threats
against Barkat. The complainant, Mohammad Arif, is also said to have
established a group that has sworn to kill Barkat.
(d)
Habib Masih, a Christian leader in Shanhkot, Sheikhupua, near
Lahorem was arrested for blasphemy in November 1993 after an amulet
containing verses of the Koran was found on the road. Local clergymen