A/HRC/25/49
challenging authority, such as the authority of official history.38 In doing so, they contribute
greatly to the promotion of critical thinking and civic engagement.
69.
Interesting experiences include those of artists questioning public calls for
memorials on specific events and the ideologies these carry, thereby opening space for
public debate and empowering victims. For example, the Monument Group, led by artist
Milica Tomić, initiated a public discussion after the city of Belgrade launched a
competition in 2002 for a memorial to the fallen fighters and victims of the 1990–1999
wars in the territory of former Yugoslavia, which led to the City cancelling the competition.
Continuing its discussions, the Group declared that each public event and discussion on
past events was in itself a monument. Discussions involving artists, professional experts
and students, but also victims and associations, succeeded in opening avenues for victims to
express themselves and create their own performances and commemorations, for example
in Omarska. Victims thus became the primary actors in constructing their own memorial.
70.
Artists too have diverging perspectives of the past and may reinforce the dominance
of one narrative, incessantly reiterated through theatre, poetry, film and painting. Such
artistic creations can be used to support the belief systems of those who maintain the
barriers of difference in societies emerging from conflict. This makes it vital for cultural
workers to be engaged in critically analysing the information that exists and to develop
meaningful collaborations and relationships with historians and academics so as to
challenge and develop the story beyond the confines of a single narrative.
71.
Interesting initiatives undertaken in this respect include, for example, a series of
walks across the border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, involving
meetings among artists, schools and community groups, culminating with the artists
inviting the public to rewrite the narrative and re-present this as publications, performances
or exhibitions. Attention is focused on memorial sites and cultural venues, with a view to
reclaiming them for pedagogical purposes – in essence a critical pedagogy of memorial and
remembrance. Another initative is a plan to produce a major new mural in Belfast to
commemorate the First World War, with a view to opening a critical dialogue with the past
that will challenge existing positions and narratives.
72.
For such initiatives to emerge, the right of each person to the freedom of artistic
expression and creativity must be respected and protected, in accordance with international
standards (A/HRC/23/34). With regard to displaying artistic expressions in the public
space, the State has a specific role in ensuring that space is made available for a plurality of
narratives and multiplying opportunities for such narratives to engage with each other.
Promoting the notion that the public sphere has to be inclusive, egalitarian and guided by
issues that revolve around the common good, rather than the promotion of particular
interests, helps to identify the conditions necessary to ensure that a democratic debate takes
place amongst citizens.39
73.
While the commissioning of a monument implies a dialogue between politicians and
artists, it is important to widen such a debate to include the communities concerned and
society at large, including those living near monuments and memorials. The message
conveyed by the artist should also be explained and introduced to the population.
38
39
Bickford, “Memoryworks/memory works”, pp. 499 and 500.
Clara Ramírez-Barat, “Transitional justice and the public sphere”.
15