A/70/301
Such expectations are linked to dominant development paradigms, which identify
foreign direct investment (FDI) and trade liberalization as strong drivers for GDP
growth.
13. International investment agreements seek to provide substantive rights to
investors that protect against expropriatory, unfair and discriminatory conduct by
States hosting investment projects. While there is some variety among the
agreements, international investment agreements often take a fairly standard format
and many countries have model bilateral investment treaties that they use as a basis
for negotiating such agreements. The standard terms within investment and free
trade agreements include provisions relating to stabilization, expropriation, fair and
equitable treatment and non-discriminatory treatment:
(a) Stabilization provisions are “choice of law” clauses that commonly
stipulate which country’s laws will govern the parameters of investment projects.
The provisions also commonly including language indicating that any future
changes in such laws cannot be retroactively applied in a way that disadvantages the
investor;
(b) Expropriation clauses seek to limit the impact of Government agencies
taking property for public purposes from foreign investment projects. Investor
agreements tend to specify that any expropriation undertaken relating to investment
projects must be in the public interest, non-discriminatory and compensated for at a
market rate;
(c) Fair and equitable treatment clauses are a core part of investment
agreements. They are broad provisions that have been interpreted to compel States to
act “consistently, transparently, reasonably, without ambiguity, arbitrariness or
discrimination, in an even-handed manner, to ensure due process in decision-making
and respect investors’ legitimate expectations”.5 Fair and equal treatment
clauses have, for example, been used to challenge taxation increases and
Government attempts to regulate harmful products such as tobacco (see A/HRC30/44,
paras. 25-27);
(d) Non-discriminatory treatment clauses specify that foreign investors from
the home country should be guaranteed treatment that is equal to nationals from the
host State and other third-party nationals.
14. Alongside the investor-State dispute settlement mechanisms, discussed below,
the provisions collectively convey a strong set of rights to investors, which have
significant and varied implications for indigenous rights and also affect the related
protective capacities of States.
C.
Investor-State dispute settlements
15. One significant feature of investment and free trade agreements are provisions
which provide for the establishment of investor-State dispute settlement
mechanisms. Those allow investors to challenge States for perceive d violations of
their rights under international investment agreements within binding arbitration
mechanisms. There is a range of arbitral forums, each with their own rules,
__________________
5
15-12526
See Fair and Equitable Treatment, UNCTAD Series on Issues in International Investment
Agreements II (United Nations publication, Sales No. E.11.II.D.15).
7/24