A/70/301
Texaco/Chevron has made several attempts to pursue damages under the bilateral
agreement between the United States and Ecuador. Arbitration is ongoing. 10
28. In 2007, the Government of Peru authorized a Canadian mining company, Bear
Creek Mining Corporation, to operate the Santa Ana silver mine. Indigenous groups
were concerned about the impact on Lake Titicaca and held a series of strikes and
blockades. Following that action, and the deaths of six protestors when police fired
on mostly indigenous protesters opposing the project, the Government was forced to
repeal the mining company’s authorization in 2011. At the same time, the
Government gave local indigenous communities the power to approve or deny any
mining or drilling operations in the area. The investor is now suing the Government
of Peru under the investment chapter of the Canada-Peru free trade agreement and
appears likely to claim expropriation of its investment. There are indications that the
Government may allow the mine to restart to avoid a costly legal battle. 11
29. Local indigenous peoples in the Plurinational State of Bolivia opposed a
mining project in the area of the Mallku Khota because of its impact on sacred
lagoons. Following strong social protest and recognition by the Government that the
project violated a number of the provisions of the United Nations Declaration on
Rights of Indigenous Peoples and the Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention
(No. 169) of the International Labour Organization (ILO), the Government reversed
the investor’s concessions. The investor sued under the United Kingdom -Bolivia
bilateral investment treaty, alleging a violation of the fair and equal treatment
clauses and expropriation, among other provisions. The Government is trying to
bring consideration of human rights, including the Declaration, into the investor State dispute settlement case, including by claiming that the investor violated
human rights, including those contained within the Declaration. 12
30. Given the multitude of mining and petroleum projects, agribusiness
investments, special economic zones, tourism developments and infrastructure
projects taking place across almost all of the world ’s continents, often on indigenous
lands, whether demarcated or not, conflicts between land rights and inve stment and
free trade agreements are likely to become increasingly common. Indigenous
peoples are vulnerable to experiencing a disproportionate burden of such conflicts,
not only due to the frequency with which their lands are used for investment -related
projects but also as a result of the additional loss of the cultural, non -economic
benefits that indigenous people often derive from land.
Free, informed and prior consent
31. The right to free, informed and prior consent is included within the United
Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples and the right to
consultation in ILO Convention No. 169. Despite those provisions, only
__________________
10
11
12
15-12526
Business & Human Rights Resource Centre, “Texaco/Chevron lawsuits (re Ecuador)”. Available
from http://business-humanrights.org/en/texacochevron-lawsuits-re-ecuador.
International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes, “Bear Creek Mining Corporation v.
Republic of Peru, ICSID case No. ARB/14/2”. Available from italaw.com/cases/2848; Mitra Taj,
“Peru hopes to revive Bear Creek mine, avoid legal battle”, 15 August 2014. Available from
http://in.reuters.com/article/2014/08/15/peru-bear-creek-minng-santaana-idINL2N0QL00Z
20140815.
Permanent Court of Arbitration, “South American Silver Limited v. Bolivia, UNCITRAL, PCA
case No. 2013-15”, 2013-2015. Available from italaw.com/cases/2121.
11/24