A/HRC/55/51/Add.2
68.
Simply put, there has recently been a major crackdown on human rights defenders and
independent journalists and the so-called voluntary self-liquidation of many civil society
organizations, many of them, if not most, connected with Pamiri grievances or the defence
of their rights.
69.
The Special Rapporteur was also informed of other steps taken by the authorities
against humanitarian and development entities related to the Aga Khan Foundation and
associated with the Pamiri, who are mainly members of the Ismaili community and recognize
the Aga Khan as their spiritual leader. In May 2023, the authorities suspended the license of
the Aga Khan Lycée, a private school in Khorog, and transferred it to the Department of
Education for its use as a State school. Other private properties seized by the State authorities
include the Aga Khan Medical Centre, also in Khorog, a $25 million facility opened in 2018,
on the very same day that the Special Rapporteur arrived to begin his country mission to
Tajikistan. The State authorities have similarly taken legal steps to seize the private
University of Central Asia, another initiative of the Aga Khan Foundation. For members of
the Pamiri minority in the Kŭhistoni Badakhshon Autonomous Province, such measures are
clear examples of the discriminatory treatment by the State authorities, dating back to the
civil war, to punish the Pamiri and their perceived disloyalty to the current regime and of the
Government’s concern about possible separatist sentiments and the loyalty of the local
population to the Aga Khan.
70.
The Special Rapporteur also met and spoke online with many Pamiri who had fled the
country following the violent events of 2021 and 2022, in addition to a few remaining in the
country, who described the threats and abuse, torture and other atrocities committed,
particularly in 2022. Their identities are being withheld by the Special Rapporteur for fear of
reprisals. What they universally described was an environment of brutality, repression and
intimidation, especially since 2021, which belies the commitments of Tajikistan towards a
greater respect for and the implementation of international human rights obligations. The
Special Rapporteur also heard that some Pamiri were executed by the Tajik special forces in
May 2022.
71.
To protect the identity of those who shared the information and their family members,
the Special Rapporteur will refer to only one well-known public case to illustrate the nature
of the repression that members of the Pamiri minority have experienced and how they appear
to be particularly targeted and vulnerable to the negation of their most basic human rights.
72.
Ulfathonim Mamadshoeva, a widely respected 66-year-old journalist was sentenced
last year to 21 years in prison on charges of incitement to overthrow the Government. Her
brother, Khursand, was sentenced to 18 years in prison and her ex-husband, Kholbash
Kholbashev, was given a life sentence on similar charges, with both of them also charged
with being leading figures behind the turbulence in May 2022 in the Kŭhistoni Badakhshon
Autonomous Province. They were sentenced largely on the basis of confessions, which the
Special Rapporteur heard were made following abuse and threats to their families. He was
unable to obtain any response from the State authorities regarding those claims.24
73.
Similarly, in 2022, Faromuz Irgashev, a 32-year-old Pamiri lawyer, who attempted
unsuccessfully to run in the 2020 presidential election, was sentenced to 30 years in prison.
He was initially part of efforts in early 2022 to mediate the tension between Pamiri protestors
and the State, leading to the creation of a 44-person commission, supported by the local
authorities, involving all sides of the unrest to investigate the root of the tensions. By the end
of May 2022, however, 10 members of the commission had been charged with allegedly
forming a criminal consortium.
74.
Information received regarding other procedures suggests that fair trial standards have
been grossly violated in cases involving human rights defenders, journalists and others, such
as Zavqibek Saidamini, Abdusattor Pirmukhammadzoda and Khushom Guliam, who were
subjected to enforced disappearance, or Daler Imomali and Ulfathonim Mamadshoeva, as
24
GE.24-00946
See communications TJK 3/2022 and TJK 1/2023.
15