E/CN.4/2000/65
page 40
151. With regard to the question of evangelization and the problems arising especially in
countries traditionally tied to the Orthodox religion or to Islam, the Secretariat of State explained
that religion could not be restricted within boundaries, as that would be contrary to human rights.
On the contrary, where religion is concerned, the individual must take precedence over territorial
considerations. Thus Polish and German Catholics living in countries of the former Soviet Bloc
following the Orthodox tradition and the Christian minority residing in Saudi Arabia have
religious requirements and rights to which the Catholic Church should legitimately be able to
attend. Cardinal Silvestrini considered that the relations between the Catholic and Orthodox
Churches were gradually improving.
152. With regard to accusations that poverty is sometimes exploited for the purpose of gaining
converts to Catholicism, the Secretariat of State said that any practices of that kind in use
currently or in the past ran contrary to the Vatican’s instructions, which advocated assistance
without imposing faith. Similarly, in reply to complaints in Africa by Muslim organizations
alleging that Christianization on the continent had been favoured by colonization and that
Catholicism had been supported after colonization by aid activities, the Secretariat of State
pointed out that Islam’s resources in Africa were far greater than those of the Vatican. It was
also stated that the Church was making an effort to detach itself from any colonial legacy while
encouraging African Catholics to take their lives in hand.
3. The question of “sects or new religious movements”
153. The question of sects or new religious movements, or movements claiming to be such, is
dealt with by the Pontifical Council for Inter-Religious Dialogue, the Congregation for the
Evangelization of Peoples, the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity and the
Pontifical Council for Culture. The approach in this case is different from that adopted for
Islam, Judaism, Buddhism, Hinduism, traditional and other religions, since study and
documentation take precedence over dialogue. In 1995, the Working Group set up by the above
bodies published an anthology of texts by the Sovereign Pontiff and the Catholic Episcopate
under the title “Sects and New Religious Movements: Anthology of Texts by the Catholic
Church (1986-1994)”. This Working Group has also taken part in several meetings, including
the international symposium on “Reincarnation and the Christian message” (Gregorian
University, Rome, March 1997), the Ecumenical Conference on “Religious freedom and new
religious movements in central and eastern Europe” (Hungary, September 1997), and the
Congress on “Societies and the new religious pluralism” (Canada, August 1996). The Working
Group has identified essentially ecumenical and socio-juridical problems. Ecumenical problems
revolve around the question of proselytism. According to the Working Group, in the countries of
central and eastern Europe, the Catholic community, which is a minority, is often compared by
Orthodox believers to a “sect”. A joint document should be drafted on ecumenical rights and
duties, providing criteria for distinguishing proselytism from Christian testimony, and
fundamentalism from genuine fidelity to the Gospel. The socio-juridical problem, according to
the Working Group, resides in the fact that the new forms of religiosity constitute a challenge
both for evangelization and for fundamental values. There is therefore a need to study questions
such as how to defend not only religious freedom, but also the human dignity of every
individual, which is threatened by sectarian associations; how to safeguard the common good in
a pluralistic society against the subversive aims of certain movements; and what sort of legal
status should be granted to associations of a religious nature.