E/CN.4/2000/65
page 10
Eritrea
34.
The right to conscientious objection on grounds of religious belief appears not to be
recognized in law. Eritrea explained that, under its legislation, military service is compulsory for
a period of 18 months, consisting of 6 months of military training and 12 months of civic
activities. It stated that no exemption was provided, except in the case of persons who had
fought in the national liberation war. The Special Rapporteur’s comments on the
Republic of Korea are also relevant with respect to Eritrea.
Russian Federation
35.
It is reported that, since 1996, the Moscow Northern Administrative Circuit Prosecutor
has brought charges on five occasions against the congregation of Jehovah’s Witnesses in the
capital. The first four cases were abandoned for lack of evidence. In September 1998, new
charges were brought under the 1997 Act on Freedom of Conscience and Religious
Organizations in respect of the proselytizing activities of the Jehovah’s Witnesses, which were
deemed illegal on the grounds that they foster religious discord and are a threat to Russian family
life. If this prosecution was successful, the registration of the Jehovah’s Witnesses would be
revoked and their congregation would be banned in Moscow. The country was reportedly hit by
a wave of anti-Semitic attacks in 1999, particularly in the form of the desecration of tombs and
attacks on a synagogue and a Jewish leader. These incidents were condemned by
President Yeltsin.
36.
The Russian Federation replied that, in 1998, the Russian judicial authorities
registered 44 new local Jehovah’s Witnesses organizations and renewed the registration
authorizing 19 organizations. The leadership of the movement in Russia was registered with the
Ministry of Justice on 27 March 1991 and the registration was renewed on 29 April 1999. It was
stated that no act of discrimination on religious grounds committed by law enforcement or other
executive agencies against Jehovah’s Witnesses had been reported in recent years. With regard
to civil proceedings against the Moscow Jehovah’s Witnesses community, it was explained that
the court was considering a request by the Moscow Northern Administrative Circuit Prosecutor
for the dissolution of the community as a result of an investigation by the Prosecutor’s Office
which revealed major incompatibilities between statutes of the Jehovah’s Witnesses community
as registered and its day-to-day activities, as well as many complaints by private individuals,
especially parents whose children had been victims of action by the Jehovah’s Witnesses
(incitement to racial hatred, suicide and refusal to accept medical care, forced destruction of the
family, etc.). It was hardly appropriate to draw conclusions about any persecution or the
dissolution of the Moscow Jehovah’s Witnesses community because proceedings were under
way which guaranteed the rights of the defence and the investigation of the case had been
suspended when the court had ordered a complex evaluation of its religious, psychological and
linguistic aspects. The community continued to carry out its activities in the capital.
37.
The authorities were also of the opinion that a more in-depth analysis of the
implementation of the new Act on Freedom of Conscience and Religious Associations would
show that its application had not led to violations of the rights of citizens or the principle of the
equality of religious congregations before the law. In that connection, it was stated that, on
1 January 1999, the Ministry of Justice and its territorial offices had registered 16,749 religious