Rita Manchanda Talking points
Substantive root causes of contemporary conflicts involving minorities
South Asia region spans : 8 countries: largely constitutional democracies with fundamental rights
chapters. These states are comprised of a mosaic of ethnicities and religions…challenges of
pluralism are huge and so too is the gap in the constitutional promises made: especially in the
contemporary context of ascendant extreme ethno religious nationalism which has
reinforced structural marginalisation of minority communities: i.e. structural inequality,
discrimination, institutionalised exclusion and state complicity in the targeted persecution
and repression of minorities amidst a culture of impunity--- It is an ‘othering’ of minority
communities –produced by deficits of democracy, development and justice.
Minority Crisis in several of the countries has reached a new threshold --pick out three
developments 1) In India practices of religious discrimination, prejudice and persecution have
got formalised into state laws and policy --manifest in a slew of laws : Freedom of Religion
Acts, Prohibition of Conversion laws, Cow Protection Acts and Citizenship Amendment Act
(2019) which introduced for the1st time a religious clause into the secular framing of
citizenship law.
2) Explicit targeting of minority communities : stigmatization and disproportionate
persecution and violent assaults, the spread of anti-minority hate speech with impunity -here single out role of the state agencies and especially state driven narratives in the
othering and positioning of entire communities as suspect rendering them vulnerable to mob
violence: anti minority spin has become default narrative : Covid and stigmatization of
minorities
3. Aggressive silencing of any counter narrative: stifling independent civil society fact
finding efforts, reports of journalists and lawyers are suppressed and activists and victimss
are harassed, assaulted and charged with a battery of violations including anti security laws
while likely perpetrators roam free.
The crackdown on civic and human rights movements has disproportionately impacted
marginalised communities
SA has become a region in which -peaceful protest gets conflated with violent politics, and
ethno-nationalist and ethno-religious struggles get conflated with ‘terrorism’ .