A/HRC/27/52/Add.1
peoples and the Ministry of Education have identified a lack of funding as a factor that
hampers the development of programmes in that field. Moreover, even though the
introduction of a curriculum suited to the needs of indigenous peoples is required by law,
teachers still tend to follow the national curriculum.
Health
66.
Both government representatives and representatives of indigenous peoples
acknowledge that the health status of indigenous peoples are negatively affected by poverty
and extreme poverty, low levels of education, limited access to drinking water and
sanitation, and the geographical isolation of many indigenous communities in Panama.
67.
The available figures point to a gap between the indigenous and non-indigenous
populations in terms of health conditions. For example, nationally, the average infant
mortality rate stands at 13.2 deaths per 1,000 live births. The averages for the Kuna Yala
and Ngobe-Bugle comarcas are 19.5 and 20.8,51 respectively. The national average
maternal mortality indicator for Panama is 80.5 deaths per 1,000 live births, while the
averages for the Kuna Yala and Ngobe-Bugle comarcas are 542.3 and 300.5,52 respectively.
68.
Indigenous peoples also tend to suffer from higher rates of infectious diseases. The
incidence of tuberculosis has been identified as an issue of particular concern, with the
Kuna Yala and Ngobe-Bugle comarcas having the highest rates: 163.3 cases per 100,000
inhabitants and 85.3 cases per 100,000 inhabitants, respectively (compared to the national
average of 41.2).53 The indigenous areas also have the highest rate of malnutrition among
children of preschool age (under 5 years of age), and this situation has worsened over the
past few years.54
69.
In general, the indigenous peoples expressed concern at the limited availability of
health services in rural areas. The number of health workers in the comarcas and other
areas with large indigenous populations remains low, although the situation is improving.
In 2011, medical-worker density in the Ngobe-Bugle comarca was 2.6 (an increase of 0.8
as of that year) and 13.0 in the Kuna Yala comarca (up from 10.9 in 2001).55 A study on the
health status of the indigenous peoples of Panama showed that 64.2 per cent of the
indigenous persons who were interviewed identified distance as being an obstacle in terms
of access to health services.56
70.
The Government runs a number of programmes designed to facilitate access to
health services. For example, it provides subsidies and transportation to clinics for
midwives, has set up hostels and homes for expectant and new mothers close to major
health-care centres and arranges for visits to indigenous communities by health workers
trained to provide basic services. However, much remains to be done in this regard. One
issue raised by the representatives of the Ministry of Health is that non-indigenous health
workers are often unwilling to work in the comarcas despite the higher wages on offer.
Cultural and linguistic factors also can interfere with access to health services. According to
representatives of the Ministry of Health, most health workers in the comarcas should be
indigenous persons who are familiar with the comarca laws. One of the many problems in
this area has to do with the sensitization of health workers.
51
52
53
54
55
56
GE.14-07234
Ibid., p. 74 (figures for 2011).
Ibid., p. 80.
Ibid., p. 101.
Ibid., p. 124.
Ibid., p. 162.
Ministry of Health and Pan American Health Organization, Diagnostico Situacional y Plan de Salud
para los Pueblos Indígenas de Panamá, p. 45.
17