A/HRC/28/64/Add.1
stated that they had alerted authorities about such incidents and called for heightened
security, including police patrols of Roma settlements, to protect Roma from further
attacks. They urged the affected Roma communities to file complaints about violence or
threats although they indicated that the Roma were fearful of doing so given the lack of
trust in police forces in some locations.
67.
The Special Rapporteur visited a Roma community on the outskirts of Kyiv. Over
100 people, including more than 60 children, were living on a rubbish tip in basic shelters
of wood and tarpaulin. The community scavenged scrap from the site which they sold to
local merchants. Community members described their situation, which included a shortage
of food and drinking water, and poor sanitation, health and access to health care. None of
the children were in school and they were clearly inadequately dressed for the low
temperatures. The community members stated that they had travelled from Uzhgorod
owing to the lack of work or income-generating opportunities there and in the hope of
finding a better situation. The community needs urgent intervention to improve living
conditions and ensure the health, well-being and access to education for their children.
X. Conclusions and recommendations
General comments
68.
Many persons belonging to minorities in Ukraine have strong, distinct
historical, ethnic, religious and linguistic identities that they wish to maintain and
express, as well as strong cultural, economic, social or linguistic connections with kinStates. Their historical and group narratives are frequently heavily influenced by
those ties. Despite previous periods of political and social upheaval since
independence, harmonious relations have endured between different population
groups and equal treatment was described in most areas of life. Many minority
representatives emphasized their minority status while asserting their desire to build
their futures as equal citizens of Ukraine.
69.
Ukraine is a relatively new independent State, following a long period of
historical Russian linguistic and cultural hegemony. In the current context it should
be recognized that a gradual decline in the influence and extent of a formerly
dominant minority language and culture does not automatically indicate evidence of
discrimination or human rights violations. However, while it is legitimate for the
Government to foster Ukrainian national identity and language, that must be
conducted in a manner which respects, protects and promotes the rights of minorities.
Sensitivity must be exercised to ensure that no law, policy or programme has
discriminatory intent or effect.
70.
Ukraine has a legislative and policy framework and environment that are
generally consistent with the provisions of the Declaration on the Rights of Persons
Belonging to National or Ethnic, Religious and Linguistic Minorities and that are
generally conducive to the protection of minority rights, including their civil and
political and economic, social and cultural rights.
71.
As in many States, the infrastructure for minority rights protection requires
strengthening and development and complaints by minorities must be addressed
appropriately. That should be achieved in full consultation with minorities. It is
essential that any revisions to existing legislation and policy, as well as newly adopted
laws, including relating to the status and use of minority languages, fully conform
with international standards relating to equality, non-discrimination and minority
rights.
18