56 19) Ramona Flores: She died on July 16, 1995 from pneumonia. She was not given medical care before she died. She was sixty-five years old. Her daughter is Leonidas Fernández. 20) Pedro Fernández: He died on October 12, 2001 from pneumonia. He was not given medical care before he died. He was seventy-nine years old. His daughter is Leonidas Fernández. 21) Eusebio Ayala: He died on March 16, 1998 from pneumonia and hypertension. He was not given medical care before he died. He was eighty years old.163 His daughter is Elsa Ayala. 22) Lucia Aponte: She died in 2002 from tuberculosis, a disease she had suffered for several years. She was not given medical care before she died; she had been treated several times before, but she “would not finish treatment because she could get the medicines in Concepción or in other cities” She was 50 years old. Her sons are Elodio, Sindulfo, Ricardo, and Zunny Ramírez. 23) Marcos Chávez: He died in 2000 from a polytraumatism caused during an occupational accident. He was not given medical care before he died. According to his next of kin, he fell off a horse while he was working at Diana estate, from where he “was brought back to the Community and abandoned there, dying later due to the trauma suffered.” He was 70 years old.164 His daughter is Mónica Chávez. 24) Antonio Alvarenga: He was allegedly murdered on August 6, 1998 by another member of his Community. He died a few minutes after the attack. He was eighteen years old.165 His grandparents are Víctor Alvarenga and Victorina Galarza. 25) Wilfredo González: He died in 1997 in an alleged traffic accident. He was not given medical care before he died. He was twenty years old.166 His mother is Guillermina Aponte. 26) Teresio González: He died on May 11, 2003 in an alleged traffic accident. He was not given medical care before he died. He was sixty years old.167 His wife is Guillermina Aponte. 163 Cf. statement rendered by Mr. Pablo Balmaceda before a public official whose acts command full faith and credit on January 17, 2006, supra note 44. 164 Cf. statement rendered by Mr. Pablo Balmaceda before a public official whose acts command full faith and credit on January 17, 2006, supra note 44. 165 Cf. statement rendered by Mr. Pablo Balmaceda before a public official whose acts command full faith and credit on January 17, 2006, supra note 44. 166 Cf. statement rendered by Mr. Pablo Balmaceda before a public official whose acts command full faith and credit on January 17, 2006, supra note 44. 167 Cf. statement rendered by Mr. Pablo Balmaceda before a public official whose acts command full faith and credit on January 17, 2006, supra note 44.

Select target paragraph3