21
Organization of American States — OAS), tending to recognize the jus standi of the
indigenous peoples (either before the conventional human rights organs of the
United Nations, or before international human rights tribunals — the Inter-American
Court or the European Court). In the context of the assertion of the international
legal personality of the members of the indigenous communities, and of their
practicing their international legal capacity, their rights to their ancestral lands have
acquired special importance75.
59.
It has been suggested that such endeavors have resulted from an ethical
imperative, in order to acquit a historical debt the international community feels it
owes the indigenous peoples, to make up for the injustices caused them at both the
material and spiritual levels. More so than in the case of other minorities, awakening
human conscience, universal legal conscience, to the need for enshrining the jus
standi of the indigenous peoples takes the form of a true ethical imperative to acquit
an historical social debt76. It is therefore not at all surprising that studies oriented
towards the protection of the rights of the indigenous peoples are currently spawning
in the most encouraging way77.
60.
The breaches of the human rights of the indigenous peoples, and the
reparations due them are to be found, in fact, at the roots of the historical process
whereby the law of nations, jus gentium, was formed. The renowned Relecciones
Teológicas by Francisco de Vitoria, specifically the famous De Indis — Relectio Prior
(1538-1539), as well as the Tratados Doctrinales (1552-1553) by Bartolomé de las
Casas, provide overwhelming evidence thereof, dating back to the 16th century.
Both authors developed their solid arguments in defense of the rights of the
indigenous peoples on the grounds provided by natural law.
61.
In his renowned 16th century Relecciones, F. de Vitoria insisted on the need
of faithfully observing the humanity principle (recalling comments by Cicero), to face
the "many atrocities and cruelties well beyond all humanity "78. F. de Vitoria affirmed
that indigenous people may not be prevented from “having true and lawful
75
.
A. Meijknecht, Towards International Personality: The Position of Minorities and Indigenous
Peoples in International Law, Antwerpen/Groningen, Intersentia-Hart, 2001, page 227, and cf. pages 134,
172, 175 and 213.
76
.
Ibid., pages 228 and 232-233.
77
.
Cf., inter alia, for example, R. Stavenhagen and D. Iturralde, Entre la Ley y la Costumbre - El
Derecho Consuetudinario Indígena in América Latina, México, Instituto Indigenista Interamericano/IIDH,
1990, pages 15-388; R. Stavenhagen, Derecho Indígena y Derechos Humanos in América Latina, México,
El Colegio de México/IIDH, 1988, pages 9-353; A.A. An-Na'im, Human Rights in Cross-Cultural
Perspectives - A Quest for Consensus, Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania Press, 1992, pages 189384; P. Thornberry, International Law and the Rights of Minorities, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1992, pages
329-382; P. Thornberry, Indigenous Peoples and Human Rights, Manchester, University Press/Juris Publ.,
2002, pages 1-429; P. Pérez-Sales, R.B. Herzfeld and T. Durán Pérez, Muerte and Desaparición Forzada in
la Araucanía - Una Aproximación Étnica, Santiago de Chile, Ed. LOM/Universidad Católica de Temuco,
1988, pages 7-300; S.J. Anaya, Indigenous Peoples in International Law, 2a. ed., Oxford, University
Press, 2004, pages 3-291; N. Rouland, S. Pierré-Caps and J. Poumarède, Direito das Minorias e dos Povos
Autóctones, Brasilia, Edit. Universidad de Brasilia, 2004, pages 9-608; J. Castellino and N. Walsh (eds.),
International Law and Indigenous Peoples, Leiden, Nijhoff, 2005, pages 89-116 and 249-267; S. Tristán
Donoso, Régimen de Propiedad de Pueblos Indígenas, Panamá, Centro de Asistencia Legal Popular, 1993,
pages 3-62; J.E.R. Ordóñez Cifuentes (coord.), Análisis Interdisciplinario de la Declaración Americana de
los Derechos de los Pueblos Indígenas, México, UNAM, 2001, pages 1-160.
78
.
Cf. F. de Vitoria, Relecciones del Estado, de los Indios y del Derecho de la Guerra, 2a. ed.,
México, Ed. Porrúa, 1985 [reed.], pages 95-96 and 98-99.