A/HRC/42/37/Add.2
40.
These customary practices and traditions revolve around the concept of
intergenerational responsibility to protect lands and resources to sustain the present and
future generations. This is reflected in their customary value, ema iha oan, rai la bele iha
oan (people can have children, land cannot), which also seeks to ensure equal access for all
to lands and sufficient resources to sustain the population. 15 The indigenous culture of the
Timorese is closely interlinked with their relationship to their lands, the environment and
the whole ecosystem. Most of the lands are community lands that may be utilized by all of
its members, who have the collective obligation to protect and preserve them. Individual
ownership usually covers agricultural and household lands.
41.
Land registration or certification is a foreign concept, as the Timorese traditionally
identified boundaries to their lands through customary practices, without codification.
When Indonesia occupied the country, it introduced property ownership in line with
Indonesian laws, resulting in the issuance of some 44,000 titles, in contrast to the small
number issued by the Portuguese of about 3,000. 16 During the Indonesian occupation,
individual certificates giving title to customary lands were issued to people who may not
have had any traditional relationship to the lands. Timorese who were forcibly displaced
during the conflict but later decided to return were faced with people who had occupied
their lands in their absence. At the end of the occupation, a strong movement to revive or
strengthen customary laws and practices emerged, especially in relation to land and the
environment.
42.
The Special Rapporteur recognizes the efforts of the Government to address the
complex issues relating to land in the country. The Constitution of Timor-Leste recognizes
traditional norms and customs, which include customary concepts of landownership and
management. In 2017, the law on the special regime on the determination of ownership of
land17 was passed. This was supposed to be the legislative response to the complex issues
regarding land, including addressing competing claims. However, in the two years since its
adoption, most of the complementary laws required to implement the Land Law have yet to
be drafted.
43.
Despite the fact that legislation remains pending, the Government has launched land
registration projects. The first land registration scheme was the Ita Nia Rai (Our Land)
project initiated a decade ago. The second is the Sistema Nacional de Cadastro (National
Cadastral System), launched in 2014 and ongoing. The previous land registration scheme
did not foresee the registration of community lands, while such provisions have been
included under the current project. However, very few communal titles have been
registered and concerns have been raised that sacred sites, water resources and other
protected areas of communities have not been adequately mapped.
44.
The Special Rapporteur was told that many people have received little or no
information about the ongoing land registration process, do not fully understand the impact
and implications it will have on their customs and traditions, and were not adequately
informed or consulted before or during the implementation. It is reported that most of the
land that has been registered so far has been registered as private titles with one owner,
while much of the land should have registered as customary land. Furthermore, measures
have allegedly not been taken in the registration process to consider the specific needs of
vulnerable groups such as the elderly, widows, persons with disabilities and orphans. The
Special Rapporteur was informed that the lack of community participation risks increasing
tensions and conflicts over lands and resources.
45.
Information received indicates that land disputes are still most often settled through
the customary justice system. In meetings with the Special Rapporteur, government
officials voiced their support for the customary system and recognized its efficiency in
settling land disputes, noting that the customary justice system is better understood and
15
16
17
8
Rede ba Rai (Timor-Leste Land Network), Land Registration and Land Justice in Timor-Leste:
Culture, Power and Justice (2013).
D. Fitzpatrick, Land Claims in East Timor (Canberra, Asia Pacific Press, 2002).
Land Law, No. 13/2017.