E/CN.4/2006/16
page 12
intercultural encounter thus generates an identity-related tension which lies at the heart of the
process of multiculturalization. Depending on the nature of the initial perception of diversity,
whether cultural, ethnic or religious, identity-related tension is subject to a particular reading or
interpretation or to a particular use, as determined by the value system of each group, community
or people. Intercultural encounter thus functions through the cultural perspective from which
peoples, communities and groups brought together within a given national framework perceive,
compare, measure, oppose or acknowledge each other. Identity-related tension constitutes the
engine of an ongoing process of reciprocal reconstruction of identity on the part of communities
brought into contact. Identity-related tension is inherent in cultural diversity. It expresses itself
in two major constituents of the identities of groups and communities and hence two areas
subject to the multicultural process which profoundly structure discriminatory practices:
memory and values.
32.
The memory factor in multiculturalism concerns the place of particular memories of
various components of a multicultural society in the national collective memory. Memory being
the expression of the historical and identity-related experience of each community over a long
period, multicultural societies are by their very nature receptacles of plural memories. The
identity-related tension of memory stems from the latent or overt conflict between the
construction of a national memory by the group or dominant community and the claiming by
other groups or communities, whether or not minority, of an acknowledgement, complete and
full, of their particular memories. The national memory, officially sanctioned and legitimized
through its place in the national history books and transmitted through the national education
system, is generally built on the basis of two principles: negation, dismissal or misrepresentation
of the specific memories of minority groups or communities and the promotion of the memory
construct of the group or dominant community. Tension arises as a result of the fact that the
memory of the dominated groups or communities is suffused with conditions, manifestations and
expressions of the domination of which they were victims. History and heritage are the major
battlegrounds of this conflict of memories in multicultural societies. The dominant national
memory usurps the recording and teaching of the national history and the designation of what
should represent the national heritage. National citizenship is also organized around symbolic
events, emblematic of national identity. These relate to historical, cultural and religious events,
to places and to figures that exemplify national values and the national identity and which,
through their commemoration and incorporation into the national cultural and social landscape,
are intended to be acknowledged, memorized and celebrated by the model citizen. Historical
overlooking of events and actions, the invisibility of personalities and places evoking memories
and the reduction to folklore of cultural and spiritual expressions characterize the treatment and
place in the national consciousness of dominated or minority groups and communities. This
conflict of memory and heritage increases the initial identity-related tension and gives a meaning
and substance to the visions and policies of integration and/or maintenance of cultural identity in
any multicultural society. The multicultural dynamic thus has a fundamental relationship with
memory.
33.
The ethical issue, the question of values, constitutes a central dimension of the
multicultural process and a particularly sensitive element in countering discrimination in a
multicultural society. It is in the domain of cultural and spiritual or religious values that the
identity of each group, community and people is most deeply rooted and is most sensitive. This
identity-related tension is reflected, in the multicultural process, depending on the historical
circumstances and political context, in the promotion and imposition of the cultural and spiritual