THE CONTRIBUTION OF NGOS TO CERD’S WORK
they can coordinate their work for the preparation of
individual reports. It may sometimes be difficult to
establish a coalition, especially because NGOs might
have diverse and sometimes conflicting positions, or
may prefer to have their own positions clearly presented
rather than having to consider certain concessions. But
despite these inconveniences, we believe there is much
to be gained from such an approach because of the
greater impact the report will have on CERD members.
Also, since NGOs with an established international reputation have often been recognized for the credibility of
the information they provide to various UN bodies, some
form of affiliation with such NGOs may enhance the status and credibility of domestic NGOs.
International NGOs experienced in the work of CERD,
such as ARIS, can also be of great help to national NGOs
for such purposes as access to the UN; lobbying and
identifying Committee members who might be interested in the issues of their concern; collecting documents;
and, in the absence of the NGO s representatives in
Geneva, handing out the supplementary report directly to
members of the Committee.
Mundo Afro, a Uruguayan NGO which submitted a supplementary report to CERD in August 1999, for the first
time, informed us of their positive experience with international NGOs: they had received assistance from
IMADR and ARIS in preparing their report as to its format, language and argumentation; in contacting the
Country Rapporteur for Uruguay; in sending two of their
representatives to Geneva who circulated copies of the
supplementary report among members of CERD; and in
organizing an informal briefing session.
... the government — It may be useful if domestic NGOs
not only discuss the preparation of the report with the
government concerned, but also let the government s
delegation know what questions NGOs will recommend
members of the Committee to ask during the consideration of the report. It often happens that the delegation
may not have the data or the competent staff available
and that the answers will be deferred to the next time a
report of the country will be examined (i.e. two years
later at the earliest); such delays can be prevented by providing the government with advance information.
... parliamentarians —This may be especially useful in
states where the government is very sensitive to concerns
raised by the legislature, and indirect lobbying through
parliamentarians may be considered.
... the media —The media can be a valuable partner in
informing the public about the consideration of the
report. In cases where there is a correspondent or a local
branch of the national media of the country concerned in
Geneva or nearby, contacts may be established with both
the headquarters in the country and the correspondent —
if possible in person. In cases where no such branch
exists, it is still worth trying to encourage the national
media to send a reporter to Geneva. Approaching international media that follow UN events is another way to
enhance NGOs advocacy work in connection with
CERD s consideration of a state report. In order that the
issues of particular concern and/or significance can be
covered properly, NGOs might consider briefing people
responsible for the media about those issues, the scope
and content of the Convention, and the procedures of the
Committee.
How to write a supplementary report37
Structure:
● Front page: An important purpose of a report is to
attract the attention of the Committee members. The
front page should give essential information regarding the country, and the name of the organization that
has prepared the report.
● Table of contents: Again for the purpose of attracting
the attention of Committee members, a detailed table
of contents should be included, not only to give Committee members a clear idea about the content of the
report, but also to enable them to refer directly to the
particular points they are interested in.
● Introduction: We have to assume that Committee
members will encounter names of NGOs which they
may not know and the introduction should therefore
contain a short description of the mandate and nature
of the NGOs. The introduction should also contain a
summary of the main points.
Illustration — The preface of the report of the Swiss
NGO Forum Against Racism starts with:
‘The “Forum against Racism” is a coalition and network of
more than eighty anti-racism organisations and numerous
individual members in the whole of Switzerland. It was
founded in the autumn of 1991 after a series of attacks
against accommodations of asylum seekers. The forum
wants to promote the exchange of information between its
members and the public and try to exercise its influence at
the national and the international level.’38
ICERD: A GUIDE FOR NON-GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS
13