E/CN.4/1996/72
page 40
of action to combat racism, xenophobia, and anti-Semitism. It also
established the European Commission against Racism and Intolerance. A
European Parliament resolution of 23 April 1993 was the first to recognize
Holocaust denial as an integral part of racist agitation.
10.
In March 1993 the United Nations Commission on Human Rights condemned
anti-Semitism for the first time in three decades, but this was not followed
up by the World Conference on Human Rights, despite a recommendation to that
effect by the Vienna NGO Forum. The United Nations did, however, create two
new posts which were potentially of particular significance. The first was
the High Commissioner for Human Rights and the second was the Special
Rapporteur on contemporary forms of racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia
and related intolerance, who was specifically charged in 1994 with monitoring
manifestations of anti-Semitism.
11.
During the summer of 1994 we submitted to the Special Rapporteur two
volumes of research on contemporary forms of anti-Semitism, and in the fall
of 1994 welcomed the opportunity of discussing the issue with the Special
Rapporteur at great length. We thus looked forward to the appearance of the
Special Rapporteur’s first report.
12.
While we were encouraged by parts of the report, we were deeply
distressed to find that certain sections contributed to the phenomenon it was
written to combat: Paragraph 22 endorsed the view that anti-Semitism is
"compounded by the economic power of the Jews". Paragraph 37 alleged that
anti-Semitism is caused because "certain adherents of Judaism continue to
treat Christ as an imposter". Paragraph 62 noted that the number of cases of
anti-Semitic attacks in Germany had risen in the previous two years from 40
to 63, but concluded by minimalizing this number with the gratuitous comment:
"Acts directly against Jews have ... increased to a lesser degree than those
directed against foreigners in general". Furthermore, the use of the term "in
general" conveyed the impression that Jewish citizens of Germany are to be
regarded as foreigners. In paragraph 24 the report also lauded the UNESCO
Conference on Cultural Policies, held in Mexico City in 1982, for its support
of the equal dignity of all cultures and the affirmation of the value of
cultural diversity. As participants in that conference, we found that in
contrast to earlier UNESCO conferences and exhibits, it excluded any mention
of Jewish culture and history.
13.
It is our profound hope that these problematic references will be
eliminated and that the United Nations will no longer be perceived to be
promoting hateful anti-Semitic stereotypes. In that regard we respectfully
urge the Special Rapporteur to recommend that the Commission on Human Rights,
in keeping with the Copenhagen document of the CSCE, propose to the
General Assembly that it forcefully condemn anti-Semitism and call upon all
Member States to do the following: to condemn anti-Semitism in all its forms,
to enact and implement legislation outlawing racial discrimination and racial
incitement to violence, and to sponsor or conduct anti-bigotry programmes at
all educational levels.
-----