A/HRC/4/9
page 24
II. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
A. Conclusions
101. In all countries, developed and developing, the high levels and disproportionate poverty
of persons belonging to minorities requires dedicated attention and concerted action. The initial
step for States in designing development policies must be to assess their obligations under
human rights treaties and customary law. Within the wider framework of a human rights-based
approach to development, the rights to non-discrimination, to participation in decision-making
and to protection of cultural identity are crucial to addressing the inequality and exclusion faced
by many minorities.
102. The Millennium Declaration establishes an overarching commitment in Goal 8 to
“develop a global partnership for development”. Developed countries and the international
community have a shared responsibility to address more fully the structural issues facing
developing countries in eradicating poverty in general and specifically disproportionate poverty
among minorities.38
103. The situation of minority women demands particular attention. The intersection of
discrimination on the basis of gender and minority identity should be considered systematically
in the reform of policies aimed at poverty elimination. It is well accepted that women from
marginalized populations are the overwhelming number of those living in poverty worldwide.
B. Recommendations
104.
The Independent Expert recommends that States:
(a)
Gather data on key economic and social indicators concerning the human
development of persons belonging to minorities, including through censuses or sampling
surveys, to establish sufficient baseline data to design appropriate policy responses. The
data, disaggregated by different specific ethnic, religious and linguistic group and also by
gender, should be made public.
(b)
Establish mechanisms for meaningful dialogue with representatives of
minority communities about development policies, particularly at the local government
level. At the national level, the creation of statutory bodies composed of representatives of
minority communities mandated to review and monitor government policy as it may affect
minorities has proved useful.
38
Philip Alston, “Ships Passing in the Night: The Current State of the Human Rights and
Development Debate Seen Through the Lens of the Millennium Development Goals”,
Human Rights Quarterly, 27.3 (2005) pp. 775-777.