A/78/180
53. While access to justice is often recognized by States in law, migrant workers
typically do not have recourse to enforceable, timely and affordable remedies,
including access to an independent, fair tribunal and to legal aid as necessary,
regardless of nationality, migration or residence status. For example, in Brazil,
although migrant workers seeking remedies for human or labour rights violations
could in principle bring a case against a recruitment agency under the country’s penal
code for fraud, the realities of corruption, slavery and trafficking and cross -border
migration in the region mean that this is insufficient to ensure access to justice, and
instead requires stand-alone legislation to address the scale and complexity of
international recruitment. 70 In most cases, migrant workers do not have unrestricted
and effective access to judicial remedies without fear of reprisals and expulsions. As
noted above, migrant workers face barriers to lodging complaints against their
employers, recruiters or others, including on grounds of sexual harassment in the
workplace, and have little access to remedies for unpaid wages and compensation for
violations of labour rights and other human rights violations. Women migrant workers
are often in the unregulated informal economy, further limiting their options to access
to justice and undermining their possibilities of acquiring regular migratory status.
D.
Rights-based approaches to ensuring the labour rights of migrants
54. Some good practices have been implemented by States and civil society which
strengthen their alignment with commitments under international law and are more
consistent with labour standards. Such practices range from r egularization
programmes for migrant workers with irregular status, pathways to permanent or
secure migration status for those on temporary work permits or under temporary
migration programmes, to ensuring equality of access to social protection,
standardized contracts for migrant workers and establishing firewalls between
services and immigration enforcement. Below are some promising practices.
55. A domestic workers’ trade union in Argentina, the Unión Personal Auxiliar de
Casas Particulares, works to improve awareness and access to new labour policy changes
in Argentina. In collaboration with the Government, the union has developed a website,
a smartphone app and introduced video toolkits 71 about domestic worker rights,
including wages, freedom of association and paid leave. The mobile app makes this
information easier to access and provides contact information for organizations and
government offices where workers can seek remedies. This particular government–trade
union model is being explored for replication in other South and Central American
countries. 72
56. Toolkits have been developed by Governments and non -governmental
organizations to improve awareness among migrant workers seeking justice. Migrant
health-care workers – in particular Indian and Filipino nurses in countries of
destination such as Denmark, Finland, Germany and Norway – have access to a tool
developed by Public Services International that outlines grievance mechanisms in
specific migration corridors which workers can contact in times of distress. 73
57. In Canada, migrant workers are permitted to apply for an open permit, through
the Open Work Permit for Vulnerable Workers, which allows them to sear ch for a new
__________________
70
71
72
73
23-13823
ILO, The Migrant Recruitment Industry: Profitability and Unethical Business Practices in Nepal,
Paraguay and Kenya (Geneva, 2017). Available at www.ilo.org/global/topics/fair-recruitment/
WCMS_574484/lang--en/index.htm.
See www.upacp.org.ar/?page_id=3017#derechosLaborales.
ILO, “Trade Union Action to Promote Fair Recruitment for Migrant Workers”, ILO brief, April 2020.
See www.ilo.org/dyn/migpractice/migmain.showPractice?p_lang=en&p_practice_id=130 .
17/21