A/HRC/46/34
studio in Chile, projected the word hambre (hunger) on the Telefónica tower in Santiago on
the same day poor residents, chanting “we are hungry”, protested the socioeconomic impacts
of lockdown measures. Subsequently, the artists were denounced by a deputy and were
subjected to threats and abuse on social media. 50 A subsequent projection of the word
humanidad (“humanity”) was rendered illegible by a light from a truck reportedly protected
by police.
21.
Some artists have been targeted for work through which they critically assess official
and public responses to the pandemic. For example, the Special Rapporteur has been deeply
concerned about the jailing, on 5 May 2020, of Bangladeshi cartoonist Ahmed Kabir Kishore
under the Digital Security Act of 2018, following the posting on Facebook of a series of his
cartoons entitled “Life in the time of corona”, critical of the Government’s handling of the
public health situation during the pandemic. Mr. Kishore is a diabetic and faces heightened
risk from the virus.51
22.
In April 2020, journalists Masoud Heydari and Hamid Haghjoo were arrested in the
Islamic Republic of Iran in connection with a cartoon that had been posted on the Telegram
channel of the Iranian Labor News Agency, on the grounds of “insulting the sanctity of
Islam” and “insulting the Islamic Republic’s Supreme Leader”. The cartoon depicted the
Supreme Leader, Ali Khamenei, as a nurse, and mocked cleric Abbas Tabrizian and Mehdi
Sabili, who had claimed they had developed treatments for COVID-19.52
23.
In Brazil, the Minister of Justice and Public Security, André Mendonça, called for the
investigation of political cartoonist Renato Aroeira after he created a satirical cartoon
criticizing President Jair Bolsonaro and the Government’s handling of the pandemic. Mr.
Aroeira is charged under article 26 of the National Security Law 7170/1083, and could face
a four-year prison sentence if found guilty of defaming the President. 53
24.
The repression of artistic voices seeking to engage critically with issues relating to the
pandemic and responses to it not only gravely undermines the rights of artists but also
threatens societies as a whole. As the former Special Rapporteur on freedom of opinion and
expression noted in his report on the COVID-19 pandemic, in the face of a global pandemic,
the free flow of information, unhindered by threats and intimidation and penalties, protects
life and health and enables and promotes critical social, economic, political and other policy
discussions and decision-making.54
25.
The Special Rapporteur’s concern about imprisoned cultural rights defenders and
artists has heightened during the pandemic, with every such imprisonment possibly becoming
a de facto death sentence due to the increased risk of contracting COVID-19 in prison and
limited medical care.55 In accordance with COVID-19 guidance posted by the Office of the
United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, States should urgently explore
options for release to mitigate the risk of harm.56 The Special Rapporteur calls for all those
imprisoned for their artistic or cultural work or their work as cultural rights defenders to be
immediately released. She has drawn attention to a number of cases. For example, along with
other special procedure mandate holders, she has urged the release of Yahaya Sharif-Aminu,
a 22-year-old musician sentenced to death for blasphemy in Nigeria based on a song he
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
8
See https://lab.org.uk/chile-censored-humanity/. See also
www.facebook.com/AtRiskArtists/videos/284091775981571/ (in Spanish).
“UN experts: Bangladesh should release artist jailed over cartoons”, 16 December 2020. See also
communication BGD 7/2020, available at
https://spcommreports.ohchr.org/TMResultsBase/DownLoadPublicCommunicationFile?gId=25739.
See contribution from Freemuse and https://cpj.org/2020/04/iran-arrests-2-journalists-for-allegedlysharing-c/.
See Cartoonists Rights Network International, “Cartoonists targeted in Bolsonaro’s Brazil”, and
https://extra.globo.com/noticias/ministro-da-justica-pede-investigacao-de-charge-que-associabolsonaro-ao-nazismo-cita-lei-de-seguranca-nacional-24481117.html (in Portuguese).
A/HRC/44/49, para. 6.
WHO, “Preventing COVID-19 outbreak in prisons: a challenging but essential task for authorities”
(23 March 2020).
See COVID-19 guidance, people in detention and institutions, available at
www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/COVID19Guidance.aspx.