E/CN.4/2006/16/Add.3
page 19
65.
The Special Rapporteur noted the almost complete lack of representation of Blacks and
Indians in State institutions. In Bahia State, for example, Afro-Brazilians constitute the majority
of the population and their cultural and religious vitality illustrates the Brazilian identity, which
is proudly displayed nationally and internationally, yet they are not visible in the highest levels
of city and State power. This is striking. The State of Bahia confirms the fact that in a situation
of profound systemic discrimination, cultural promotion does not necessarily result in political
participation. On the contrary, cultural promotion is in fact used as a disguise, a mask behind
which is hidden the de facto social, economic and political discrimination and exclusion suffered
by these communities.
66.
Racism and racial discrimination are more deeply cultural and historical in nature and
touch the central issue of national identity. The Special Rapporteur noted with concern the lack
of a national memorial on slavery, which appears as a denial of the place of slavery in the
national memory of the country. In the same spirit, the over-exploitation of the Afro-Brazilian
and indigenous heritage and culture for tourism without meaningful social and economic
benefits, is a source of profound frustration and alienation for their communities. More recently,
their spiritual and religious traditions are being threatened by the unchecked aggressive
proselytism of some powerful evangelical groups. The process of profound destruction of the
cultures of the Indigenous peoples can be seen in the slow disappearance of their languages.
67.
The Special Rapporteur notes with satisfaction the recognition by the federal Government
of how deeply rooted racism is in Brazil and its effects on the structure of the entire society since
it was founded. He also notes that a promising legislative framework including programmes,
mechanisms and institutions have been put in place to combat racism and racial discrimination.
He notes however, with concern, the resistance to the federal Government policies within the
society, within the Governments and the judiciary at the State level, where the ideology of racial
democracy still determines perceptions and policies.
68.
Accordingly, recognizing the determination of the Government to eradicate all forms,
manifestations and expressions of racism and racial discrimination, and with the view of
strengthening its political will and enlarging its promising policies, the Special Rapporteur
submits to the Government, in the following section, a number of recommendations relating to
its political and legal strategy, but also the need of an intellectual, cultural and ethical strategy in
order to eradicate the deeper roots and manifestations of racism and racial discrimination, which
are debilitating the political, human, social and economic future of Brazil.
V. RECOMMENDATIONS
69.
Much depends on the success or failure of the Government of Brazil in eradicating
racism and racial discrimination, not only in terms of the strengthening of democracy, and
social and inter-ethnic harmony in Brazil but also for all countries of the South American
region with similar historical legacies of racism and racial inequalities. Unrecognized by
most of these Governments, racism and racial discrimination are still prevalent to different
degrees and are deeply rooted in their societies.
70.
Given the historical, social and cultural entrenchment of racism and racial
discrimination, efforts to combat and eradicate their roots, manifestations and expressions
should be undertaken as a process of national catharsis in two key steps: