E/CN.4/2006/16/Add.3
page 10
26.
Concerning discrimination, the FUNAI president stated that Indians may feel
discriminated against in the South, where they may be seen as weird, but in the rest of the
country they are well accepted and recognized as part of the nation.
The judiciary
27.
According to Vice-President of the Federal Supreme Court, Ellen Gracie Northfleet, and
Joaquim Barbosa, the first Afro-Brazilian judge of the Federal Supreme Court, judges need to
become aware of their prejudices: measures should be taken, mainly through training, to avoid
such prejudices influencing their decisions. Judges already receive similar training in gender
discrimination. The Supreme Court does not have many opportunities to debate questions of
racial discrimination, since reaching this level is expensive for most cases. However, in the
verdict on a recent case involving an anti-Semitic publication, the Court took a clear stance
against racial discrimination, stating that freedom of expression does not include the
dissemination of discriminatory messages. The Court will soon have a new opportunity to
examine this issue in an appeal relating to the unconstitutionality of quotas. The two judges
praised the important work done by the Labour Public Prosecutor concerning collective actions.
28.
The judges of the Tribunal of Justice of the State of Pernambuco indicated that
discrimination is not racial but socio-economical in Brazil. There is no racism based on ethnic
diversity, people live together harmoniously and there has been no case of conviction for racism
in the tribunal. They indicated that it is rare to see a Black or Indian judge, but not because of
racism. The tribunal is now working on the recognition of marriage under the Condomblé
African religion.
The Office of the Public Prosecutor
29.
The Office of the Public Prosecutor is an independent entity in Brazil. It is entrusted with
the promotion of justice, but also with the protection of the democratic system. The federal
public prosecution office for civil and criminal affairs indicated that the legal system is good yet
insufficient. Most worryingly, the implementation of the law is difficult since the idea that
discrimination is economic and not racial prevails in public institutions. An experimental project
to fight against institutional racism is being launched by SEPPIR, the Department for
International Development, UNDP, the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural
Organization and the public prosecutors of the States of Bahia and Pernambuco. The federal
public prosecutor is also launching a programme to identify institutional racism within its office.
As a matter of fact, there are few black prosecutors in the country.
30.
The labour public prosecution office is doing a very interesting job in the field of racial
discrimination in employment. Based on the fact that the numerous cases of racially motivated
refusal of recruitment are difficult to prove (in the history of the labour tribunal, there have been
only five cases of convictions for racism), the office launched a project to sensitize the five
largest private banks on this issue. An assessment study showed that while black people
represent 50 per cent of Brazil’s active population, these banks employ 43.7 per cent white
women, 37.7 per cent white men, 10.6 per cent black men and 8.1 per cent black women. While