A/HRC/49/46
any submission from United Nations entities or mechanisms that directly addressed the issues
of conflict prevention and the protection of the human rights of minorities.
66.
Many of the submissions made to the Special Rapporteur by States Members of the
United Nations did include reports on their constitutional, legislative and other measures to
protect the human rights of minorities, including some that referred to autonomy or internal
self-determination arrangements that had been implemented in order to provide an additional
layer of protection of the rights of minorities and a degree of guaranteed political
representation and control over important matters for the identity of minorities. Far fewer
submissions from Member States, however, made any kind of direct connections between
conflict prevention and early warning measures that focused on the grievances of exclusion,
discrimination and inequalities affecting minorities as potential drivers of conflict and the
human rights dimensions of these grievances.
67.
Submissions from civil society organizations, particularly those representing
minorities and working on minority issues or in States and regions affected by conflicts, were
significantly more on topic and often reflected concerns over the denial of the human rights
of minorities as prime drivers of conflicts. This was particularly the case in the
recommendations made by civil society organizations at the 2021 Forum on Minority Issues
and the four regional forums. A recurrent theme has been the need to better protect the human
rights of minorities to prevent conflicts, and the strong urging that efforts to do so should
include a global instrument for elucidating specifically what the rights of minorities are, so
as to better ensure their implementation – and thereby better prevent conflicts. A small
number of submissions from civil society organizations raised general allegations of breaches
of the rights of specific minorities, without referring directly to any conflict prevention
context or issue.
V. Conclusions and recommendations
68.
The world seems to be darker and nastier for minorities, as well as hateful and
violent.
69.
The political and social landscapes in many parts of the world have for years
been flashing warning signs: long-standing grievances of exclusion, discrimination and
inequalities – and therefore breaches of the rights of minorities – are more often than
not the precursors and drivers of today’s violent conflicts. Injunctions more than a
decade ago warning that the international community needed to acknowledge and take
steps to mainstream minority rights frameworks in conflict prevention initiatives went
almost completely unheeded, though some States Members of the United Nations have
taken steps in this direction. For their part, civil society organizations, particularly in
conflict-ridden societies, have been urging action in increasingly hostile environments
of intolerance, of marginalization and even of incitement to hate and violence targeting
minorities, and often of rising populist majoritarian ethnocentrism. It is not unfair to
describe the lack of responses at the global level as a systemic failure of the international
community, since violations of the human rights of minorities are obvious warning signs
of approaching conflicts.
70.
The Special Rapporteur invites States, United Nations entities, regional
organizations and non-governmental organizations to recall the recommendations
made by the Independent Expert in her 2010 report.
71.
The Special Rapporteur urges in particular United Nations entities and regional
organizations to move towards the development and institutionalization of normative
frameworks, based on the international human rights of minorities, that provide both
relevant conflict analysis tools and conflict prevention mechanisms.
72.
The Special Rapporteur recommends in particular the drafting of a global
instrument on the human rights of minorities and the creation of conflict prevention
mechanisms, such as the OSCE High Commissioner on National Minorities, in order to
better reflect and respond to the nature of existing and future conflicts and hence offer
more targeted and relevant tools for the analysis and prevention of contemporary
16