A/55/280
While the paper’s management attempted to
justify their provocative position on the grounds
that they were upholding religious convictions,
their real motives appear to have been rooted in
an attempt to win electoral support with a view to
the prospective legislative elections, in which the
Labour Party intends to participate.
order to contain and prevent events such as those
described above.
20. The Special Rapporteur regrets the lack of effort
and care taken over this reply, which is no reply at all,
and requests Egypt to communicate its views and
comments on the allegations summarized above.
21. According to another communication from the
Special Rapporteur, the Supreme Religious Court in
Cairo declared the Baha’i faith a dangerous heresy in
1925. In 1960, all Baha’i assemblies were reportedly
dissolved, their property and other assets confiscated,
and their religious activities prohibited. Nonetheless,
Baha’is supposedly remained free, as individuals, to
practise their faith, in accordance with the freedom of
religion that is guaranteed for all under the
Constitution. To this day, however, the Baha’i
community is said to be subjected to constant close
surveillance. Baha’is are reportedly not allowed to
meet in groups, especially for religious observances,
and their literature is destroyed. It is alleged that they
cannot legally celebrate their marriages, which are
deemed to constitute concubinage, while the children
born of these unions are regarded as illegitimate.
22. According to a third communication, since May
2000 a hate campaign has been waged in Cairo by
extremists against the author Haidar Haidar, who is
accused, together with his publishers, the Ministry of
Culture and liberal intellectuals, of blasphemy because
of his novel A Feast of Seaweed. According to
information from a variety of sources, this affair is
being politically exploited by Muslim extremists,
especially the Muslim Brotherhood, in the context of
the coming legislative elections.
23.
Egypt has replied:
Concerning the campaign against the
Minister of Culture and the Syrian author, Haidar
Haidar, when the General Assembly of Houses of
Culture decided to publish a play entitled A Feast
of Seaweed, the newspaper The People (formerly
published by the Labour Party, whose activity has
been suspended) took advantage of the
opportunity to launch a media campaign against
Ministry of Culture officials for publishing
material that was secular in nature and was also,
according to the paper, contrary to religious
values and principles.
Concerning measures taken to prevent extremists
from taking over mosques, Egypt has the following to
say:
Management of all mosques and shrines has
been centralized in the hands of the Ministry of
Awqaf (Islamic Endowments). That Ministry now
has responsibility for 50,000 mosques and 10,000
shrines;
Every person not expressly authorized to do
so is prohibited from mounting a mosque pulpit
and delivering a sermon, inasmuch as the law
requires a statement from the Ministry of Awqaf;
There have been various judicial measures
aimed at thwarting any attempt to make use of
mosques for unlawful purposes.
Russian Federation
24. On 11 August 1999, in St. Petersburg, the
Jehovah’s Witnesses reportedly applied for a permit to
rebuild a religious centre. On 22 November 1999, the
Governor’s office allegedly replied that, in the first
place, the St. Petersburg Jehovah’s Witnesses had
enough religious centres to meet their needs, and in the
second place, because of the state of public opinion in
the city, it would be “inexpedient” to open an
additional centre.
25.
The Russian Federation has replied:
The matter referred to in the Special
Rapporteur’s letter is exclusively technical in
nature and is unrelated to the issue of freedom of
religion.
For
the
Special
Rapporteur’s
information, the facts are as follows.
Block 3A, at 18 Pogranitchnika Garkovogo
Street in St. Petersburg, is a former municipal
building, now vacant, that has been acquired by
the head office of the congregation of Jehovah’s
Witnesses. On 15 August 1999, the congregation
applied to a number of the city’s subdivisions and
administrative services for authorization to
7