A/72/165
accepted. Arab populations were mentioned in 12 recommendations to 4 countries:
Israel (8), Islamic Republic of Iran (2), France (1) and the United States (1). The
Islamic Republic of Iran and the United States noted the recommendations; the rest
were accepted. Christians were mentioned in 11 recommendations to 9 countries:
Islamic Republic of Iran (2), Pakistan (2), the Central African Republic (1), China
(1), Indonesia (1), Israel (1), Nigeria (1), Turkmenistan (1) and Uzbekistan (1). A
total of 5 were noted (by China, Islamic Republic of Iran, Pakistan and Uzbekistan)
and 6 were accepted. Of the 11 recommendations that mentioned the Baha’is, 10
were to the Islamic Republic of Iran and 1 was to Indonesia. Indonesia accepted the
recommendation, while Iran noted all of them.
95. There were 15 recommendations in the second cycle (compared with 41 in the
first cycle) that referred to treaty bodies and minorities: 12 were accepted a nd 3
noted. There were 13 recommendations referring to special procedures and
minorities: 7 of them were accepted and 6 noted. A total of 5 referred to the
Independent Expert or the Special Rapporteur on minority issues.
96. With respect to areas of concern contained in the recommendations, the
analysis revealed 33 main thematic areas: access, birth registration, citizenship,
criminal justice, culture, discrimination, education, employment, equality, ethnicity,
hate or hatred, health or health care, housing, human rights, intolerance or
xenophobia, judicial matters, land rights, language-related matters, legislation and
the law, media, nationality-related matters, participation, police, poverty, protection,
racism, religion or belief, segregation, social inclusion, torture, training, violence
and water and sanitation.
VII. Conclusions
97. The year 2017 marks the twenty-fifth anniversary of the Declaration on
the Rights of Persons Belonging to National or Ethnic, Religious and Linguistic
Minorities. The anniversary constitutes a reminder and a crucial opportunity
for States to strengthen their respective legislation on minority rights
protection to ensure that it is fully in line with the Declaration. The Special
Rapporteur recalls the four pillars of minority rights protection that should be
reflected in those laws: first, the protection of a minority’s survival by
combating violence against its members and preventing genocide; second, the
protection and promotion of the cultural identity of minority groups and their
right to enjoy their collective identity and to reject forced assimilation; third,
the guarantee of the right to non-discrimination and equality, including ending
structural or systemic discrimination and the promotion of affirmative action,
when required; and fourth, the right of minorities to effective participation in
public life and in decisions that affect them. She stresses that
non-discrimination clauses, which provide for equal treatment for all members
of society, without the aforementioned additional guarantees, have often proved
insufficient for the effective protection of disadvantaged minorities.
98. The United Nations in general should advocate minority rights protection
more strongly at both the national and regional levels, with a view to ensuring
that States strengthen their legal, policy and institutional frameworks and that
regional anti-discrimination and minority rights standards and mechanisms are
put in place for the protection and promotion of minority rights, respectively.
99. Equally, the United Nations should ensure that the composition of its staff
in all offices and entities, in particular in the field, reflects the national, ethnic
and religious make-up of the societies in which they operate.
17-12138
21/22