A/69/266
violent conflict is higher where there are significant horizontal inequalities in
political or economic status between different ethnic or culturally defined groups. 7
Indicators demonstrate how higher rates of educational attainment can lower the risk
of internal conflict. In 2009, of the world’s 101 million children out of school, an
estimated 50 to 70 per cent were members of minorities or indigenous peoples. It is
essential that minorities be integrated and able to benefit from development policies.
The Special Rapporteur dedicated her annual report to the Human Rights Council in
2014 (A/HRC/25/56) to the importance of including minorities in the planning,
implementation and evaluation of new development goals in the post-2015
development agenda, as a means to reduce inequalities.
B.
Deficits of democracy, good governance and rule of law
19. While violence can occur in any country, those in which there is a function ing
democracy, good governance and the rule of law are less likely to experience
violence against specific communities. Competition for resources and positions are
natural in all societies and should pose no threat to any community. However, where
democracy, rule of law and governance deficits are coupled with competition over
territory, resources and power, where bias politics and favouritism along ethnic or
religious lines appear, and where minority rights are denied, violated or neglected,
tensions between communities can evolve, threatening peace and stability and
sometimes resulting in violence. Strong institutions and independent, efficient law
enforcement and judicial bodies, as well as independent national human rights
institutions, can act against corruption and exclusion before misuse of power starts
to fuel community tensions.
20. The peoples under threat index of Minority Rights Group International is
based on known antecedents to mass violence, including indicators of good
governance, rule of law, prevailing conflict and previous mass killings. It was found
that communities are more at risk in closed States that have poor governance, are
prone to conflict and have a record of previous killing. In three quarters of recent
conflicts, much of the killing has been targeted by ethnicity or religion. While ethnic
diversity in a State is not positively correlated with risk of conflict, risks rise
sharply when sociopolitical divisions in society fall along ethnic or religious lines. 8
21. After her visit to Nigeria in February 2014, the Special Rapporteur on minority
issues noted that some of the tensions and conflicts that had erupted in Nigeria’s
northern states and states in the country’s middle belt had been depicted as religious
or ethnic conflicts. However, she found that, while the tensions and conflicts had
obvious religious and ethnic dimensions, their root causes lay also with other
factors, including poor governance, competition for or unequal allocation of
resources, land issues, political manipulation of ethnic and religious issues,
population movement and migration. She considered that, while enhancing the
capacity, training and resources of the security forces in regions where violence had
broken out was essential, sustainable solutions to commu nal violence must also
__________________
7
8
14-58850
Frances Stewart, “Crisis prevention: tackling horizontal inequalities”, Oxford Development
Studies, vol. 28, No. 3 (2000), pp. 245-262. Available from www.unicef.org/socialpolicy/files/
Crisis_Prevention_Tackling_Horizontal_Inequalities.pdf.
Peoples under Threat 2011. Available from www.minorityrights.org/10744/peoples-underthreat/peoples-under-threat-2011.html#downloads.
7/24