E/CN.4/2004/76
page 15
57.
The Special Rapporteur has observed that migrant domestic workers rarely report their
employers and seek protection. There are various reasons for the absence of complaints: a fear
of being arrested and deported for illegal residence; the fact that their situation depends entirely
on the employment relationship with their employers; the lack of identity documents; the lack of
access to protection mechanisms; ignorance of the language; and debts in their countries of
origin. Migrant domestic workers are not always entitled to remain in the country while their
cases are being dealt with; when they are, they are not always entitled to work, which means that
without assistance from the State they do not have the means to live. The Special Rapporteur
was informed that the competent authorities do not pursue those responsible for abuses, such as
withholding passports or wages, despite the complaints submitted by migrant domestic workers.
58.
Furthermore, when migrant domestic workers are explicitly excluded from the labour
legislation of the host country they cannot claim any rights. In situations where domestic work is
considered informal, the only means of settling disputes is through amicable settlements.
59.
In the case of women working for diplomatic staff or staff in international organizations,
the employers enjoy total immunity from the host country’s criminal legislation and partial
immunity from its civil and administrative legislation. In such cases it is virtually impossible for
women to claim their rights.21
60.
Consulates are supposed to furnish assistance to nationals in the territory of the host
State; the protection provided, however, is not always effective. There are several reasons for
that: the migrant domestic worker’s country of origin does not always have a consulate in the
country of destination; consulates are unaware of the presence of illegal workers until they seek
protection or the host State authorities inform them of their presence; for a variety of reasons, the
workers cannot or do not wish to apply to the consulate.22
61.
Some countries make an effort to provide greater protection through programmes
targeted especially at female migrant domestic workers. Very often women who flee their
employer’s home to escape abuse and violence do not know where to turn. In Bahrain, the
embassies of the Philippines and India provide shelter to female migrant domestic workers who
have had problems with their employers. The embassy of the Philippines covers legal costs if
the case is taken to court; the embassy of India has funds available to repatriate female migrant
domestic workers who wish to escape from a situation of abuse or have had disputes with their
employers.
62.
The Special Rapporteur believes that a reliable and detailed register of migrant domestic
workers would enable the country of destination to take this occupational category into account
when formulating and planning its policies. It would also enable the consulates of the countries
of origin, besides the relevant services in the country of destination, private recruitment agencies
and NGOs, to monitor migrant domestic workers’ working conditions and to offer protection
when necessary.
63.
Some countries have legislation requiring agencies to exercise some control over
employers and check that the terms of the contract or verbal agreement regarding working hours,
wages, board, lodging, etc. are observed. Nevertheless, according to information received, the
agencies tend to favour the employer in the event of disputes and do not always intervene when
migrant domestic workers’ rights are violated.