A/77/246
internally displaced persons and protected populations under occupation or conflict
areas”, and similar listings. 33
68. In the same field, the recently adopted road map for the next decade on the
Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights 34 mentions on numerous occasions
those who may be at heightened risk of vulnerability, such as women; lesbian, gay,
bisexual, transgender and intersex persons; children; persons with disabilities;
indigenous peoples; peoples of African descent; migrants; and refugee workers.
Minorities are never mentioned. Nor again is this an omission: minorities were
referred to in earlier drafts and removed, while tellingly new vulnerable groups were
included in later drafts.
69. Information collected by the Special Rapporteur points to other areas within the
United Nations of insensitivity, misconceptions and even perceived opposition from
United Nations staff as to the rights of minorities. While holding regional forums
under his mandate in different parts of the world, the Special Rapporteur was
informed by local civil society organizations and persons belonging to minorities of
numerous instances of staff in United Nations country missions and field operations
dismissing minority concerns or denying even the existence of minorities. These
included refusals to collaborate on minority issues because a particular group was
either not considered by United Nations staff as a minority or because minority claims
involving minorities were considered too politically sensitive or complex to be
addressed officially. Among examples, it was suggested to the Special Rapporteur
that Tigrayans in Ethiopia and Shia Muslims in Yemen could not be considered as
minorities. Other occurrences have involved the Afrikaans in South Africa, Bedouins
and Arabs in Israel and Amazigh in Tunisia.
IV. Conclusion and recommendations
70. There has been a near complete failure to mainstream and integrate the
rights of minorities at the United Nations, despite the call to do so by the
Secretary-General in his 2013 Guidance Note, while there has been significant
progress for the mainstreaming of racial anti-discrimination.
71. The Special Rapporteur strongly urges the Human Rights Council to
initiate a study on how to strengthen the protection of minority rights, including
through a new United Nations treaty, and how to operationalize the Secretary General’s call in 2013 to mainstream and integrate minority rights across all
pillars and activities of the United Nations, and also urges the United Nations
system to reactivate and implement the integration of minority rights into its
work at the global, regional and country levels. Many submissions to the Special
Rapporteur and even recommendations made at the regional forums and the
Forum on Minority Issues have included calls for the United Nations to launch a
process such a treaty as a legitimate area of international cooperation in a
climate where there has been a regression in the international protection of
minority rights.
72. The Special Rapporteur recommends that United Nations agencies and
entities, especially OHCHR and the United Nations Development Programme
(UNDP), also prepare strategic plans to mainstream and integrate minority
rights into their work. United Nations agencies should prioritize the inclusion of
__________________
33
34
22-11516
See article 6 (4) (c), available at www.ohchr.org/Documents/HRBodies/HRCouncil/
WGTransCorp/Session6/LBI3rdDRAFT.pdf.
Available at www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/2021-12/ungps10plusroadmap.pdf.
19/21