A/HRC/31/CRP.2
35.
Participants from Peru noted the lack of specific legislation to assist Roma
communities. Indigenous peoples and other minority groups are recognized, but a
legislative and institutional silence surrounds Roma minority rights. It was suggested that
establishing public policy on Roma and recognizing Roma as a Peruvian minority might
increase trust in the Government as a partner in promoting and protecting their rights, and
that this might make individuals feel more comfortable about disclosing their Roma
identity.
36.
Participants also emphasized their wish for Roma to be able to integrate more into
Peruvian society in order to reduce marginalization and exclusion, albeit while maintaining
their distinct identity and culture. Currently, many Peruvian Roma prefer to hide their
identity, fearing that disclosing their ethnicity could lead to discrimination or have other
negative impacts.
C.
Education
37.
Almost all the participants indicated that one of the major challenges for their
communities is access to education. Literacy rates in Roma communities across the
Americas remain low, and school dropout rates high. States often highlight the itinerant
lifestyles of Roma as the key obstacle to education, but the majority of participants noted
that most Roma no longer travel. It was emphasized that experiences of discrimination are
the key challenge in terms of accessing education.
38.
Participants described hauntingly similar experiences of discrimination in terms of
access to education, from the bullying of Roma children by other students and their family
members to direct discrimination by educational administrators who refuse to enrol Roma
students in schools on the basis of their ethnic identity. Other challenges identified include
inadequate accommodation of the cultural practices of Roma students, such as Roma
languages and traditional dress, and of the specific needs of those who maintain a travelling
lifestyle. Even where overarching policies do exist to protect the right to education for all
without any form of discrimination, a lack of awareness of these laws among teachers and
school administrators, as well as a lack of awareness about Roma and their rights as a
minority group, mean that in practice, in the locations in which Roma live and where
prejudices remain alive, these laws are not implemented.
39.
The Special Rapporteur notes that all of these factors have contributed to the low
levels of educational attainment and high dropout rates among Roma communities, which
perpetuate the cycle of marginalization and exclusion.
40.
The government of Argentina has recognized that Roma communities have low
levels of literacy and high school dropout rates. The Government attributes these to cultural
factors such as nomadism and early marriage, and the practice of encouraging early entry
into the labour market.15 Participants, however, highlighted the ongoing discrimination
experienced by Roma children in accessing education as the key obstacle in this regard.
This includes direct discrimination against Roma students by both teachers and school
administrators, as well as bullying by non-Roma pupils that is often not adequately
addressed by the school authorities. Participants noted that when children with Roma
surnames try to enrol in school, they are often not accepted. They observed that while some
outreach workers criticize Roma communities for withdrawing their children from school,
Roma parents report that they have no alternative, as their children are not offered a safe
place in which to pursue their education while freely expressing their Roma identity.
15
Response of the Government of Argentina (note 9), p.6.
9