Address to UN Minority Forum on Hate Speech
19 November 2020
The UNPO is a membership-based organization of minorities, indigenous communities
and other politically marginalized groups from around the world seeking the effective
realization of their rights to self-determination.
Hate speech has long been an issue of concern for UNPO members. Many of them are
routinely publicly attacked for celebrating their linguistic, religious or ethnic cultures
because of distrust of societal diversity amongst dominant groups.
In many of the societies where UNPO members live, social media is one of the primary
sources of both communication and news. And it has become a breading ground for
hate.
Last month, the UNPO released a report, Unrepresented and Alone: The Impact of the
Coronavirus Pandemic on Unrepresented Nations and Peoples. Amongst other findings,
the report identified that that across the world, in all continents, unrepresented people
have been scapegoated for the pandemic. Underlying prejudices against linguistic,
ethnic and religious difference have been inflamed across social media.
As the report shows, online hate speech is a widespread, global phenomenon that
becomes particularly dangerous in times of crisis. It needs to be urgently addressed.
Nonetheless, we want to provide a note of caution.
Today we have submitted an in-depth study into the use of hate speech in Spain
against the Catalan minority. The report highlights that, just like with other UNPO
members around the world, the Catalan minority in Spain are widely subjected to hate
speech online.
The report notes, however, that strong hate speech legislation in Spain has been used
not to protect the Catalan minority, but rather to intimidate and prosecute Catalans
working for the right to self-determination.
This phenomenon is not limited to Spain. Much like with anti-terrorism legislation earlier
in this Century, we are noticing many instances of states overusing hate speech
legislation to target for political purposes speech that in no way relates to hate speech.
We encourage this forum to take this factor into account in its concluding report and
recommendations.
Thank you.