A/HRC/26/49
Christopher Wolf recently described the situation of how racism, xenophobia and hate
manifest on the Internet:
Today there are powerful new tools for spreading lies, fomenting hatred, and
encouraging violence. […] The openness and wide availability of the internet that
we celebrate has sadly allowed it to become a powerful and virulent platform not
just for anti-Semitism but for many forms of hatred that are directly linked to
growing online incivility, to the marginalization and targeting of minorities, to the
spread of falsehoods that threaten to mislead a generation of young people, to
political polarization, and to real-world violence.
The authors accurately perceive the dangers and challenges posed by the Internet and social
media:
Instead of being under the central control of a political party or group, the power of
the Internet lies in its viral nature. Everyone can be a publisher, even the most
vicious anti-Semite, racist, bigot, homophobe, sexist, or purveyor of hatred. The ease
and rapidity with which websites, social media pages, video and audio downloads,
and instant messages can be created and disseminated on-line make Internet
propaganda almost impossible to track, control, and combat. Links, viral e-mails,
and “re-tweets” enable lies to self-propagate with appalling speed.2
18.
The Special Rapporteur observes that there is an increasing use of electronic
communication technologies, such as electronic mail and the Internet, to disseminate racist
and xenophobic information and to incite racial hatred and violence. Right-wing extremist
groups and racist organizations use the Internet in their transborder communications and
exchange of racist materials. As technology evolves, extremist hate sites have similarly
grown in both number and technological sophistication.
19.
The Special Rapporteur notes with serious concern the use of the Internet and social
media by extremist groups and individuals to disseminate racist ideas and to propagate
racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance. This concern has also
been echoed by many States, non-governmental organizations and Internet providers and
social media platforms. One major consequence of the dissemination of such information is
that the more people see hateful information, the more they tend to accept it and believe
that the ideas are normal and mainstream.
20.
Another major concern is that extremist groups and movements, particularly farright movements, use the Internet and social media platforms not only as a means to
disseminate hate speech and to incite racial violence and abuse against specific groups of
individuals, but also as a recruitment platform for potential new members. The potential of
the Internet is used to expand their networks of individuals, movements and groups, as it
allows the rapid and more far-reaching dissemination of information about their aims and
facilitates the sending of invitations to events and meetings. The web is also used by
extremist movements and groups to distribute newsletters, video clips and other materials.
It is worrying that calls for violence against individuals and groups advocating anti-racism
activities are placed on websites and social media to intimidate, exert pressure or stop social
or political actions or activities directed against extremist groups. 3
21.
The situation of marginalized persons and groups who are discriminated against on
the Internet and social media largely reflects the challenges they face in the real world.
While Internet technology has helped to connect and empower minority groups and
2
3
6
Abraham H. Foxman and Christopher Wolf, Viral Hate: Containing its Spread on the Internet (New
York, Palgrave Macmillan, 2013).
See A/HRC/26/50.