A/65/222
B.
Decriminalizing and managing irregular migration
73. States should remove laws, policies, plans and programmes aimed at
criminalizing irregular migration and should not consider breaches of
immigration law a crime or punish such breaches with detention.
74.
In line with the foregoing, the Special Rapporteur recommends that States:
(a) Undertake policy reforms to remove detention as a punishment for
breaches of immigration laws and policies;
(b) Until such reforms are into effect, States should take all possible
measures to suspend the application of detention as an anti-immigration
measure and ensure that immigration detention is not applied to asylumseekers, children (whether unaccompanied or with families) or victims of
trafficking, labour exploitation and abuse, or to other vulnerable groups.
75. States should consider that irregular migrants are generally in a very
vulnerable condition and that irregularity is due to several factors (including
restrictive migration policies, social exclusion and marginalization as well as
demand for labour in countries of destination). States should accordingly:
(a) Adopt integrated and protective approaches, instead of approaches
that are punitive and based solely on security and border control concerns;
(b) Design and implement programmes, plans and policies to address
irregular migration in a comprehensive and holistic way, without resorting to
its criminalization;
(c) Take into account the root causes of migration and the importance of
creating legal channels for migration in policymaking initiatives so that they
can be comprehensive, human-centred and incorporate human rights;
(d) Promote multi-pronged and multi-stakeholder initiatives, preferably
including civil society and migrants themselves (such as research, advocacy
strategies, policy discussions, etc.) in order to examine the context-specific and
human rights-based options to address irregular migration.
1.
Regularization policies, plans and programmes
76. States are encouraged to adopt and promote regularization programmes,
plans and policies as a crucial strategy for ensuring migrants’ rights, prevent
human rights violations and abuses associated with irregular migration,
address marginalization and facilitate the integration of migrants and their
families in the communities of destination.
77.
States are particularly encouraged to:
(a) Develop public policies to regularize non-documented migrants
(especially children and their families) through flexible, permanent and regular
legal avenues and by extraordinary regularizations aimed at contributing to the
social integration of the large number of irregular migrants living in host
societies;
(b) Consider regularization programmes as a key element of migration
policies in order to ensure social integration and family reunification, limit
10-47488
19