Case study
Minorities in the media
Supporting minority language
media is a key way to promote
minority cultures and identities,
and provide marginalized groups
with access to information about
wider social issues. It is equally
important that minority voices
and issues are incorporated into
mainstream media and culture.
In Slovenia, Italians and
Hungarians are official national
minority communities. Under
the Constitution, minorities are
guaranteed the right to develop
activities in the field of publishing
and public media, and the state
provides financial and moral
support for this. The public
service broadcasting law has
implemented these rights and
guarantees support for radio
and television programmes for
Italians and Hungarians.
The public broadcasting
service RTV Slovenia carries,
produces and broadcasts these
programmes with support from
the government. Dedication
to coverage of minority issues
is explicit in RTV Slovenia’s
ethical code.
While positive, a question
remains about adequate
programming for other minority
communities in the country. This
underscores the need to revisit
any special measures regularly,
in order to ensure that they truly
reflect and address the concerns
of minority communities –
including those which may have
been established more recently.
States have this obligation for all
individuals but because minorities
are often more vulnerable, it is
explicitly stated here. Implementing
this article may require states
to take ‘special measures’ for
minorities to address the impact of
discrimination and specific barriers
minorities face in achieving their
rights. For example, Brazil reserves
university entrance places for
students from Afro-descendant and
indigenous communities, in numbers
proportional to their population in
each state.
2. States shall take measures
to create favourable conditions
to enable persons belonging
to minorities to express their
characteristics and to develop their
culture, language, religion, traditions
and customs, except where specific
practices are in violation of national
law and contrary to international
standards.
It is not enough for a state to just
tolerate minorities; it must actively
support minority cultures, especially
in the case of language. This requires
both institutional and economic
support and includes permitting
expression of identity and promotion
of culture. Cultural practices of any
group may not violate human rights
standards and any restrictions of
practices must have reasonable and
objective grounds.
3. States should take appropriate
measures so that, wherever possible,
persons belonging to minorities
may have adequate opportunities to
learn their mother tongue or to have
instruction in their mother tongue.
Language binds culture together, and
minorities that wish to pass on their
language to their children must be
given support to do so. Mother-tongue
education for minority children in
primary school is one way to improve
access to education and increase the
attendance of minorities at secondary
schools. Education in other national
languages should be included to
ensure access to employment and
services in the wider society.
This right is restricted by the words
‘wherever possible’, which means that
states may decide it is not realistically
feasible (for example, if the minority
is dispersed throughout the country
and there is a lack of adequate
resources to provide for mothertongue instruction).
Over the last two decades Ethiopia
has reformed education policy to
allow the use of mother-tongue
languages in primary schools, despite
relatively limited resources. Primary
level students now receive education
in a mix of their mother tongue,
Amharic (former official language),
and English depending on the region.
4. States should, where appropriate,
take measures in the field of
education, in order to encourage
knowledge of the history, traditions,
language and culture of the
minorities existing within their
territory. Persons belonging to
minorities should have adequate
opportunities to gain knowledge of
the society as a whole.
This is important because the history
and culture of minorities are often
neglected or misrepresented. Negative
stereotypes and misrepresentations
can contribute to discrimination
and sometimes xenophobia, hate
speech and violence. Encouraging
inter-cultural dialogue can help