E/CN.4/2005/18/Add.2
page 2
Summary
From 26 June to 2 July 2004, the Special Rapporteur visited Guatemala as part of a
mission to the Central American region that also took him to Honduras and Nicaragua (see
E/CN.4/2005/18/Add.5 and Add.6). He visited the country at the invitation of the Government
of Guatemala and in pursuance of his mandate. The regional mission was prompted by the need
for the Special Rapporteur to help to shed light on two particularly significant factors in the
problem of racism: (1) the depth of the historical legacy of racism and racial discrimination, the
ideological underpinning of the slave-holding and colonial systems, which has had a deep
influence on the structure of societies in the region; and (2) the impact of the political violence
that has marked the recent history of Central America on communities of indigenous people
and people of African descent, which have historically experienced discrimination. The
three countries have similar ethnic and demographic features and common historical and
political legacies and, as countries in transition towards peace-building, social cohesion and the
consolidation of democracy, are of particular interest with respect to the structuring and
management of ethnic, racial and cultural pluralism.
The Special Rapporteur observed three trends in all three countries that reveal the
existence of deeply rooted discrimination: (1) a troubling correlation between poverty-stricken
areas and areas inhabited by communities of indigenous people and people of African descent;
(2) the marginal involvement of representatives of those communities in power structures - the
government, parliament and the judiciary - as well as their insignificant presence in
decision-making positions in the media; and (3) their treatment in the media as objects of
folklore. He also found, to varying degrees in the three countries, a lack of awareness of how
extensive and deeply rooted discrimination is, among both the political authorities and the
population as a whole.
The Special Rapporteur notes, by contrast, statements by civil society actors he spoke
with, as well as testimony from members and representatives of all the peoples and communities
concerned, that the societies in Guatemala, Honduras and Nicaragua remain deeply imbued with
racial prejudice and discriminatory practices against such peoples and communities. Their
situation is a legacy of the colonial conquest and the slave-holding system, which, by
subjugating these peoples and communities and belittling their identities and cultures on the
basis of an openly racist ideology, have effectively marginalized them in a lasting way at the
political, social, economic and cultural levels. Despite principled claims of being multicultural,
the Hispanic legacy and identity of these countries are highlighted to the detriment of the
legacies of indigenous peoples or people of African and indigenous descent, which are reduced
to folklore. The rejection of the reality of ethnic pluralism, in political, cultural and social terms,
is particularly evident in everyday life through discriminatory acts such as frequent denial of
access to public places. Denying people the opportunity to express their identities is one of the
most telling forms of discrimination. The inadequacy of public services (education, health and
justice in particular) in areas inhabited by these communities and the absence of genuine
bilingualism are objective demonstrations of the lack of social and cultural integration of these
peoples and communities. Thus, indicators of health, education and housing for these peoples
and communities remain lower than for the rest of the population.