Box 4:
An MDG Report for
Afro-descendants in Ecuador
The UN Country Team (UNCT) in Ecuador
established an Inter-Agency Working Group on
Intercultural Issues. Under the auspices of this
group, a distinct MDG report was produced
focusing on the situation of Afro-descendants:
Objetivos de Desarrollo del Milenio: Estado de
Situación 2007; Pueblo Afroecuatoriano.15 The
report provides an overview of key issues facing
these communities and assesses progress
towards realisation of each of the MDGs. This
report attempts to bring the MDGs closer to
the challenges faced by the Afro-descendant
population, aiming to:
MDGs 1-7 will be explored below for the particular implications of each goal with respect to
minorities and to offer some suggestions on how
UNDP could support governments to devise
MDGs strategies that are inclusive of minorities
and respectful of minority rights.
MDG 1: Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger
Minorities often have disproportionately high
rates of poverty. Minorities frequently have less
access to employment, credit and education
opportunities, reducing economic security and
decreasing opportunities to improve human
capital. Such groups tend to live in areas with
lower government investment in infrastructure
and social services, thus diminishing their human
development and market access. Land rights
for minorities may be less secure, placing them
at higher risk of displacement, eviction and
landlessness. In times of crisis, minorities may
find it harder to access emergency aid. Access to
justice may be less secure for minorities, leaving
Undertake specific measurements,
which incorporate indicators targeting
marginalised cultural minorities;
Promote cultural policies, with concrete
measures to benefit disadvantaged
social groups;
Direct citizen participation of
Afro-descendants.
In preparing the report, the UNCT worked
with the national Corporación de Desarrollo
Afroecuatoriano (CODAE).16 Complementary
initiatives include the creation of the AfroEcuadorian System of Social Indices (SISPAE)
in the Technical Secretariat of the Ministry of
Social Development Coordination.
them unable to benefit from protective laws
and more vulnerable to harm and exploitation.
Minorities may be poorer because they have
been denied citizenship, lack equal access to
social services and full public participation.
Many experts argue that the decision to call for a
‘reduction by half’ in extreme poverty and hunger
leaves open the possibility that minorities may
constitute the majority of those persons still
living in poverty and suffering from hunger
in 2015. As a consequence, it may be that
minorities not only fail to benefit from MDG 1
strategies, but that they could also experience
significant increases in inequalities. This could
further harm national prospects for growth:
the World Bank (2005) found that “the growth
elasticity of poverty reduction falls with greater
income inequality. In other words, the impact (of
the same amount of ) growth on poverty reduction is significantly greater when initial income
inequality is lower” (p. 9). MDG 1 strategies
could provide disaggregated measurements of
Another MDG Report on Indigenous Peoples is also being prepared by the UNCT.
15
See http://www.codae.gov.ec/ (accessed 9 August 2009).
16
36
M A R G I N A L I S E D M I N O R I T I E S I N D E V E LO P M E N T P R O G R A M M I N g