Tools and Steps:
Review of legislation. The review of legislation entails: (i) identifying which international
human rights instruments have been ratified by
the State46 and the provisions regarding to your
area of work (minority rights, health, education,
etc.) in them. (ii) Reviewing national laws such
as the constitution, bill of rights, non-discrimination and gender-equality laws, civil and penal
codes, human rights case law, laws on decentralization, etc., and identifying the provision
regarding your area of work (health, education,
etc.) and, (iii) reviewing other commitments
entered into at recent world conferences insofar
as they bear upon human rights, including the
United Nations Millennium Declaration (2000)
or the World Conference Against Racism Durban
Declaration and Programme of Action (2001)
and identifying provisions regarding the project
area of work.
Identifying features of human rights-based
local service delivery. Using the information
gathered, the project team must identify what
the local government’s obligations are vis-à-vis
local citizens in the specific area under analysis,
as well as the responsibilities of the regional
and central government with regard to the
specific area.
Identification of duty bearers at all levels in
administration, including local and national
governments, authorities, departments and relatives and other civilians with duties. This may be
done within the applicable legal framework for
the area of the planned intervention.
Map out the relationships between the duty
bearers and claim holders following the legal
framework that you have mapped out. This step
gives a more detailed description of the actual
entitlements and claims of rights holders vis-àvis duty bearers and what the channels are for
working with them.
Conduct the capacity assessment by identifying
the rights holders and duty bearers of the
planned intervention. Assess the gaps in their
abilities to claim, fulfill and protect rights.
Examples of issues to investigate
undertaking capacity assessment:
when
Why do rights holders face difficulties in
claiming their rights?
Is there policy and law in place to claim the
specific right at local level?
Is there policy on the right and access to
information?
Do they have access to information?
Are these norms and regulations being
implemented?
Do right holders have the ability to organize
themselves?
Are they empowered to claim rights?
Why do duty bearers fail to respect protect and
fulfill rights?
Analysis needs to be directed towards mandate and resources
Is the mandate to fulfill a right on the side of
the local government?
Have law and policy been put in place to
regulate the specific right?
Are there sufficient budget allocations?
Are there sufficient financial and knowledge
resources?
The assessment forms the basis for capacity
building activities, which are undertaken during
the implementation stages of the project.
Similarly, indicators are used to assess the impact
after the activity.
For this, see http://www.ohchr.org/EN/Countries/Pages/HumanRightsintheWorld.aspx (accessed 9 August 2009).
46
Chapter 8: Situation Analysis Tools
127