A/HRC/24/52
required in understanding the concept and what needed to be done to put it into action for a
holistic approach beneficial to people of African descent. She indicated the possibility of
the need for a global forum for people of African descent to further the discussion in that
matter.
32.
Ms. Najcevska presented a paper on “Recognition through data collection: Mapping
Inequalities”. She highlighted the importance of data collection in depicting racial
discrimination and further noted that data collection and analysis could be an essential tool
for assessing whether rights under the international and national laws were being infringed
and taking corrective action. She also added that the statistical presentation of
disaggregated data could be used as an appropriate tool, especially in dealing with
structural discrimination.
33.
She also mentioned the challenges due to the lack of insufficient statistical data on
people of African descent and their resulting invisibility. Similarly, according to her, the
lack of a regional or international protection regime designed specifically for people of
African descent highlighted the necessity of further developing the international legal
framework. She then detailed the need to develop ethnic and racial categories to meet the
needs of the national anti-discrimination scheme and enable measuring. Prohibition of data
collection on the basis of race in some countries served to inhibit the tracking of racism and
anti-Semitism and also made monitoring the progress of anti-discrimination programmes,
legislation and other initiatives difficult. She concluded by stating that solid disaggregated
data on people of African descent was sine qua non in the recognition of the specific
indirect and structural discrimination those persons were facing, but cautioned that, while
data disaggregated by race and ethnicity might make racism and racial discrimination more
visible, it could also be misused and misinterpreted and could lead to racial profiling or
feed stereotypes and prejudices.
34.
Carlos Viáfara, a professor of Economics at the University del Valle in Cali,
Colombia, delivered a presentation entitled: “Colombia a case study: A social pyramid of
pigmentocracy”. He stated that, while the subject of his presentation was a case study of a
specific country, it was generally relevant to and reflective of the situation of people of
African descent in other parts of the world. The presentation was based on comprehensive
research undertaken by The Project on Ethnicity and Race in Latin America (PERLA), a
joint project led by Princeton University and the University del Valle and other
organizations, in relation to ethnic-racial issues concerning people of African descent, their
construction of self-identity and other identity markers. The Project analysed the ethnic and
racial inequalities in the educational attainment and income status of the household average
in Colombia and other countries in the region. According to the comprehensive survey
undertaken by PERLA, unlike existing models (which provided clear and distinctive
categories of racial identities), in the Colombian case, ethnic and racial identities were very
porous and understood in context of fusion, of the “dark” to “clear”. The PERLA survey
utilized colour palettes instead of self-identity categories, to analyse how the external
appearances through colour intensity of the skin affected access to valued resources at the
societal level. One of the major findings of the survey was that the Afro-Colombian
population, in particular people with darker skin tones, had a lower status in terms of
socioeconomic achievement. This was not only attributable to historical factors but also to
the presence of institutions that had reinforced discrimination, resulting in a continuing
inequality trap in the long run.
35.
He concluded by offering a number of recommendations, such as the need for
countries to follow the experience of Brazil, Ecuador and the Bolivarian Republic of
Venezuela in their 2015 population and housing census and ask people of African descent
to identify themselves on the basis of an ethnic or racial category. He also emphasized the
need to introduce the ethnic/racial variable into household and quality-of-life surveys,
forms, administrative registers and statistical processes in general, in order to measure
discrimination and formulate, implement and monitor appropriate public policies. He also
9