A/HRC/12/34
page 22
consent or agreement of the indigenous peoples concerned. Hence, consultations should
occur early in the stages of the development or planning of the proposed measure, so that
indigenous peoples may genuinely participate in and influence the decision-making.
66. The principle that indigenous consent should be the objective of consultation does not
mean that obtaining consent is an absolute requirement for all situations. In all cases, what
fundamentally matters is that a good faith effort by the State is made to achieve agreement.
Indigenous peoples, as well, should seek in good faith to reach consensus on proposed
measures and avoid inflexible positions when the proposed measures are based on
legitimate public interests.
67. Notwithstanding the necessarily variable character of consultation procedures in
various contexts, States should define into law consultation procedures for particular
categories of activities, such as natural resource extraction activities in, or affecting,
indigenous territories. Such mechanisms that are included into laws or regulations, as well
as ad hoc mechanisms of consultation, should themselves be developed in consultation with
indigenous peoples.
68. Consulting with indigenous peoples on the very elements of the consultation
procedure to be employed not only helps to ensure that the procedure is effective, it is
also an important, necessary confidence-building measure. Other measures for
confidence-building are also needed.
69. In this regard, States should make every effort to allow indigenous peoples to
organize themselves and freely determine their representatives for consultation
proceedings, and should provide a climate of respect and support for the authority of those
representatives. For their part, indigenous peoples should work, when needed, to clarify
and consolidate their representative organizations and structures in order that they may
function effectively in relation to consultation procedures.
70. States should also develop adequate analyses and impact assessments of proposed
legislative or administrative measures, and make them available to the indigenous peoples
concerned along with all relevant information well in advance of negotiations. States should
also endeavour to ensure that indigenous peoples have adequate technical capacity and
financial resources in order to effectively participate in consultations, without using such
assistance to leverage or influence indigenous positions in the consultations.
71. Relevant agencies and programmes within the United Nations system, as well as
concerned NGOs, should develop ways to provide indigenous peoples with access to the
technical capacity and financial resources they need to effectively participate in
consultations and related negotiations.
72. Even when private companies, as a practical matter, are the ones promoting or
carrying out activities, such as natural resource extraction, that affect indigenous peoples,
States maintain the responsibility to carry out or ensure adequate consultations. For their
part, as a matter of policy if not legal obligation, private companies should conform their
behaviour at all times to relevant international norms concerning the rights of indigenous
peoples, including those norms related to consultation.