A/57/274
8.
On 27 May 2002, the Special Rapporteur sent a
communication about a popular Tunisian singer, Dhikra
Mohammed, who was reportedly sentenced to death by
a fatwa pronounced by a judge of the Islamic High
Court of Riyadh, Sheikh Ibrahim al-Khdairi, for having
compared her sufferings to those of the prophet, thus
committing an act of apostasy liable to the death
sentence; she is said to have denied showing any lack
of respect towards the prophet.
9.
By letter dated 27 May 2002, the Government
responded notably:
“There is no so-called ‘Islamic High Court’
in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. The
Government is in no way associated with this
information. That information which evidently
concerns a person who expressed an opinion in
his personal capacity does not reflect the point of
view of the Government or any of its judicial
authorities and, consequently, is totally
inaccurate.”
10. The Special Rapporteur, while taking due note of
Saudi Arabia’s reply, wishes to point out in this respect
that it is the duty of the State to counter all forms of
intolerance and discrimination based on religion or
belief and to ensure that freedom of opinion or
expression, as well as freedom of religious belief, is
safeguarded within the framework and the limits
envisaged by international law.
11. By letter dated 28 March 2002, the Special
Rapporteur informed the Government that he had
received reports that, on 11 March 2002, some girls
who were escaping from a burning school at Mecca
were prevented from leaving by members of the
Committee for the Propagation of Virtue and the
Prevention of Vice on the ground that they were not
wearing the appropriate clothing required in public
places. The Committee members also reportedly
opposed the rescue operation because the rescuers were
men. Fifteen girls are said to have perished and dozens
of others to have been injured. A number of girls who
successfully escaped are alleged to have been beaten
publicly because they left the school improperly
dressed.
12. By letter dated 4 June 2002, the Government
responded notably:
“The regrettable fire in which a number of
girls lost their lives was an accident caused by
4
one of the students. The allegation that members
of the Committee for the Propagation of Virtue
and the Prevention of Vice in any way bore
responsibility for their deaths is totally
unfounded, as confirmed by the investigations
that were conducted after the fire, the results of
which were made public. The exaggerated
manner in which the allegation portrays that
accident and links its consequences to
intervention by members of the Committee for
the Propagation of Virtue and the Prevention of
Vice is fabricated, implausible and totally lacking
in credibility. There is a definite similarity
between this and other recent allegations derived
from some information media which have been
transmitted to us. The responsible officials are
making every endeavour to preserve the safety
and dignity of citizens and foreign residents and
would never allow them to be subjected to any
form of humiliating or degrading treatment or
encroachment on their rights.”
13. On 8 February 2002, the Special Rapporteur sent
a communication about seven persons belonging to the
Ismaili community, including Duhayman Muhammad
al-Hatila and Mish’il al-Hussain Barman bel-Harith,
said to be detained in al-Hai prison in Riyadh and in
danger of being executed. These people are said to
have been among the hundreds of demonstrators who
were allegedly arrested in April 2000 by Saudi security
forces when they were protesting in Najran following
the closure of their mosque and the arrest of a person
suspected of witchcraft.
Azerbaijan
14. On 12 February 2002, the Special Rapporteur sent
a communication to the Azerbaijani Government
concerning two leaders of an unregistered Pentecostal
church, Yusuf Farkhadov and Kasym Kasymov, who
were reportedly arrested by the police and officers of
the Ministry of National Security during a religious
meeting in a private apartment on 18 January 2002,
sentenced to two weeks’ imprisonment on 21 January
2002 and held in Sumgait prison. Three members of a
Baptist church are also said to have been held in
Sumgait and threatened by the police with two weeks’
imprisonment for distributing Bibles in the street on 2
February 2002. One of them, Rauf Gurbanov, is alleged
to have been severely beaten by the police.