A/HRC/10/66
page 13
76.
The Chairperson opened the floor for comments and questions.
77. One observer emphasised the importance of a rights based approach and that what children
say must be taken into account. It was noted that children represent the present and not just the
future. It was also stressed that the Convention on the Rights of the Child is the most
comprehensive legal framework on child rights and must be the cornerstone for any action to
further the protection of children. One observer stressed that States should take effective
preventive measures with the aim of eliminating juvenile crimes.
78. Panellist Renato Roseno made a presentation on the situation of children of African
descent in Brazil, with a focus on violence. It was noted that they face multiple forms of
discrimination. The concept of intersectionality comprising the coexistence of different factors
such as race, gender, social class, violence etc. helps us to understand the complexity of groups
and situations. It was noted that discriminatory practices are acute, inter alia, in the realms of
university education, employment and mortality rates. These children are more often victims of
violent attacks. It was highlighted that isolated policies tend to be inefficient and that problems
have to be addressed in an holistic manner. The need for differentiated education that respects
and preserves cultural values, history and ethnic identity was noted.
79. It was suggested that the Working Group collaborate more closely with the Committee on
the Rights of the Child and ensure participation of children in meetings that the Working Group
carries out during country visits.
80.
The Chairperson opened the floor for discussion.
81. An observer suggested that efforts should be made to reconstruct the image of people of
African descent as this would have an impact on social attitudes towards them. It was also
suggested that young people who are deprived of their history are apt to fill this gap with
criminal figures as role models and points of reference.
82. The issue of children who are born and raised in a developed country and then deported,
was mentioned as a concern. Furthermore, the so-called “zero tolerance” and “safe” policies at
schools result in the expulsion of boys of African descent who end up in criminal gangs. It was
also noted that a disproportionate number of children of African descent remain in the childcare
system in developed countries as there are no foster parents for them, which results in a loss of
identity.
Children of African descent and human rights mechanisms
83. Panellist Veronica Birga made a presentation on the work of treaty monitoring bodies and
special procedures mandate holders with regard to children of African descent. During the
review of the respective recommendations, the issues of birth registration, nutrition, school
attendance and drop out, mortality rates and access to healthcare services were highlighted,
among others. It was noted that the Committee on the Rights of the Child also pointed out the
need for disaggregated data. Race and ethnicity have been seen to affect vulnerability to sexual
exploitation and trafficking. In schools, disciplinary measures are more often taken against
children of African descent. The need for intersecting policies was emphasized.