A/HRC/50/31
lawyers, journalists and other observers by declaring a state of emergency, and by
subsequently amending the Act on the Protection of the State Border.52
37.
The Special Rapporteur is extremely concerned by the accumulated impact of these
measures on the human rights of migrants, including refugees arriving at the borders of these
States. He has been engaging with concerned States through communications53 and issued a
public statement.54 The practical implementation of restrictions have reportedly led to the
death of at least 19 migrants within the Polish-Belarusian border zone,55 with many more
risking serious illness and injury due to prolonged stays in an inhospitable environment in
the forests, without adequate assistance, and exposed to freezing temperatures. 56 Nongovernmental organizations have also recorded instances of violence from Lithuanian and
Polish border guards during pushbacks, as well as from Belarusian border guards, who forced
migrants towards the border. 57 Those summarily returned to Belarus reportedly faced illtreatment and detention as well as onward removal to countries of origin without an
individualized assessment and in breach of the principle of non-refoulement. The shuffling
of migrants across the borderline by Belarusian border guards has also led to several cases of
family separation.58
38.
In Slovenia, amendments to the Foreigners Act that came into effect in May 2021
enable the suspension of the right to asylum “in case of a migrant emergency”. In addition,
the Special Rapporteur notes with concern that parliament has failed to remedy the
malpractice of removing migrants from the country without a return decision. 59
39.
Some countries of destination have argued that their policies are the result of the
deliberate encouragement and facilitation of human mobility by other countries for political
motives.60 In this regard, the Special Rapporteur condemns the use of migrants as a political
tool in violation of their human rights and, at the same time, reaffirms that, despite those
allegations, the right to seek asylum must remain in effect under all circumstances.
2.
The impact of pandemic-related measures on border and immigration governance
40.
As documented by the Special Rapporteur, the public emergency arising from the
COVID-19 pandemic has disproportionately impacted on the rights of migrants through
border closures and emergency measures.61 Migrants continued to face restrictions on their
rights, including to liberty of movement, when left stranded or stuck at international borders
or forced to leave States.
41.
Numerous reports indicate the arbitrary and collective expulsion of over 1.6 million
migrants from the United States since March 2020, justified on the grounds of the health
emergency caused by the pandemic. The expulsion orders are issued on the grounds of Title
42 of the United States Code, enabling immigration authorities to block entry into the United
States and to expel non-citizens without adequate procedural protections, and often depriving
them of their right to seek asylum and to be protected against refoulement.62 These policies
have been continuously renewed since first enacted by the Trump administration in 2020 and
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
See Helsinki Foundation for Human Rights submission. In relation to the detention and obstruction of
the work of three journalists, the Supreme Court of Poland ruled in January 2022 that such blanket
restrictions on staying in the entire area of the border zone were unconstitutional and could not
provide legitimate grounds for criminal prosecution. See also OHCHR, “Press briefing notes on
Poland/Belarus border”, 21 December 2021.
See communications POL 5/2021 and BLR 7/2021.
See https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2021/10/belarus-and-poland-stop-sacrificing-migrantlives-political-dispute-un.
See Helsinki Foundation for Human Rights submission.
See statement by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights, 19 November 2021,
available at https://www.coe.int/en/web/commissioner/-/commissioner-calls-for-immediate-access-ofinternational-and-national-human-rights-actors-and-media-to-poland-s-border-with-belarus-in-orderto-end-hu.
See Médecins sans frontières submission No. 1.
Ibid.
See submission by the Human Rights Ombudsman of Slovenia and A/HRC/47/30, para. 66.
See submission by Greece and reply by Poland to communication POL 5/2021.
See A/76/257.
See submission by UCLA Law School.
9