A/HRC/27/65
Annex
Expert Mechanism Advice No. 6 (2014): Restorative justice,
indigenous juridical systems and access to justice
for indigenous women, children and youth,
and persons with disabilities
A.
General
1.
The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples constitutes a
principled framework for justice, reconciliation, healing and peace. It affirms that the
United Nations, its bodies and specialized agencies, and States have a duty to promote
respect for and full application of the provisions of the Declaration and follow up on its
effectiveness. Full implementation of the Declaration necessarily entails the protection and
promotion of indigenous peoples’ right to access to justice and to effective remedies.
2.
Indigenous juridical systems can play a crucial role in facilitating access to justice
for indigenous peoples. The Declaration affirms indigenous peoples’ right to promote,
develop and maintain their juridical systems or customs, in accordance with international
human rights standards (article 34). The Declaration also upholds indigenous peoples’ right
to maintain and strengthen their distinct political, legal, economic, social and cultural
institutions, while retaining the right to participate fully in the political, economic, social
and cultural life of the State (article 5).
3.
Access to justice, in addition to being a right in itself, is of paramount importance to
indigenous women, children and youth, and persons with disabilities, as a means of
obtaining timely and effective remedies. It must be viewed holistically, since access to
justice is inextricably linked to other human rights challenges faced by indigenous peoples,
including their status in society as indigenous women, children and youth, and persons with
disabilities, as well as poverty, lack of access to health and education, and lack of
recognition of their lands, territories and resources.
4.
In this regard, several recent judicial decisions highlight the role that access to
justice can play in asserting indigenous peoples’ rights over their lands, territories and
resources.65
B.
Advice for States
5.
In accordance with the Declaration, States must recognize indigenous peoples’ right
to maintain, develop and strengthen their own juridical systems, and must value the
contribution that these systems can make to facilitating indigenous peoples’ access to
justice. In this regard, States must allocate resources to support the adequate functioning
and sustainability of indigenous juridical systems and help ensure that they meet the needs
of communities, in accordance with article 39 of the Declaration.
65
See for example Tsilhqot’in Nation v. British Columbia, 2014 SCC 44 (Supreme Court of Canada),
which relates to indigenous peoples’ title to land and resources based on a territorial approach, and
Decision Number 35/PUU-X/2012 of the Constitutional Court of Indonesia, which recognizes the
rights of the Indigenous Peoples of the Archipelago over their customary forests.
21