A/71/317
• Abdulaziz al-Jobouri, head of Antiquities Security in the Province of Nineveh,
who was responsible for the protection of numerous ancient sites, was
executed by Da’esh on 16 October 2014. The mosque that he had built in his
village was subsequently bulldozed.
• Mustafa Ali Ahmad Salih and Asrawi Kamil Gad Qalayni, guards at the Dayr
al-Barsha site in Egypt, were killed on 20 February 2016 by a gang of tomb
robbers as they attempted to stop the looting of the tomb of the last ruler of the
First Intermediate Period, Djehuti-Nakht. 56
• Berta Cáceres, noted defender of indigenous rights and co ordinator of the
Civic Council of Popular and Indigenous Organizations of Honduras, who had
long campaigned to protect indigenous heritage, including natural heritage,
was gunned down in Honduras on 3 March 2016. 57
70. We must also commemorate those who fell earlier. Aida Buturovic, a librarian,
was killed by a shell burst in August 1992 as she returned home after working with
others to save the rare books and manuscripts in National and University Library of
Sarajevo on the day it was shelled. Expert bibliographer András Riedlmayer made
the following comment: “People sometimes ask me why I am worried about books
when so many human beings have died and suffered. My answer is to point to Aida
Buturovic, because the two are inseparable.” 58
71. These are only a few of the cultural heritage heroes who have fallen. The
Special Rapporteur notes that she has been unable to locate any source of
comprehensive records of the threats made to, and human rights abuses perpetrated
against, cultural heritage defenders. The greatest memorial that members of the
international community could raise to those who died defending heritage would be
a continuation of their work and the provision of support to those still on the front
lines. We must not wait until we are mourning their deaths to rally to the cause of
cultural heritage defenders at risk.
72. The Special Rapporteur has become aware of small initiatives aimed towards
supporting local cultural heritage professionals or, when the risk becomes too great,
arranging for their evacuation and thereby enabling them to work in institutions
elsewhere. Those initiatives could have exerted a significant impact but were
hampered by the inability to obtain funds, notwithstanding the international
community’s professions of outrage at heritage destruction. Such small, potentially
effective initiatives are to be favoured over mere window dressing.
73. Threats to cultural heritage defenders also pose a grave risk of the loss of their
expertise. Further, conflict situations and political turmoil frequently result in
__________________
56
57
58
20/24
Based on Dayr al-Barsha Project, “GoFundMe campaign for the antiquities guards of Dayr
al-Barsha”, 22 February 2016. Available at www.dayralbarsha.com/node/301; and correspondence
with the Dayr al-Barsha Project, directed by the Department of Egyptology, University of Leuven,
Leuven, Belgium.
Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, “Berta Cáceres’ murder: UN
experts renew call to Honduras to end impunity”. Available at www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/
Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=19805&LangID=E.
Ken Gewertz, “Librarians Riedlmayer and Spurr Honored for Work in Sarajevo”, Harvard
Gazette, 31 October 1996. Available at http://news.harvard.edu/gazette/1996/10.31/
LibrariansRiedl.html. See also András Riedlmayer, “Crimes of war, crimes of peace: destruction
of libraries during and after the Balkan wars of the 1990s”, Library Trends, vol. 56, No. 1
(2007), pp.107-132.
16-13742