A/HRC/40/64/Add.2
community participation in issues affecting their own development and affirmative
measures for the benefit of communities, including minority communities that have faced
intractable disadvantages either for logistical reasons or because of long-standing historical
prejudice and subjugation by the dominant groups. These measures cover matters such as
improved access to education; health; employment; and economic development
opportunities.
19.
With regard to education, the Government’s efforts have resulted in an adult literacy
rate of 88.5 per cent in 2015 – one of the highest in Africa – according to the United
Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), and this rate seems
to be increasing. Educational initiatives are in place to make education as accessible as
possible to all, including for inhabitants of remote areas, who are often minorities.
Religious minorities do not seem to face any major obstacles or discrimination in terms of
accessing education, and it is noteworthy that reports of hate speech or incitement targeting
such communities or other minorities appear to be practically non-existent.
20.
On the human rights front, the Government’s “Vision 2036: Achieving Prosperity
for All” initiative aims at building a united and proud nation based on the five national
principles of democracy, development, self-reliance, unity and botho.3 The Special
Rapporteur was pleased to see in Vision 2036 a statement that all ethnic groups will have
equal recognition and representation at the Ntlo ya Dikgosi (House of Chiefs). In a section
dealing with what is described as the “fourth pillar”, involving the Constitution and human
rights, the Government aims for Botswana to be “among the top countries in the protection
of human rights”. In another section of the Vision the Government recognizes the particular
cultural heritage and identity that Botswana must maintain and promote in order to achieve
an inclusive and equal opportunity nation, as well as to enable all its communities to “freely
live, practise and celebrate their diverse cultures”, including their languages. The Special
Rapporteur notes that, during the 2012 universal periodic review of Botswana, the
Government indicated that it appreciated the importance of using mother tongues for
education and that it would explore strategies for that purpose, including by introducing
teacher aides at the primary school level. It has also been brought to the attention of the
Special Rapporteur that the Government has committed to ratifying the Convention on the
Rights of Persons with Disabilities soon. In addition, there are currently discussions within
the Government to strengthen the human rights mandate of the Office of the Ombudsman
and for it to incorporate the activities of a possible national human rights institute. These,
and other initiatives to improve access to justice, health care, water and other public
services for all persons, particularly in more remote regions where minorities are
concentrated, must be commended.
VII. Challenges and implementation
21.
Despite these and other positive measures and developments, the good policies and
intentions that the Special Rapporteur often heard during his discussions around the country
were not always translated into practice and implemented.
22.
There remain issues of concern that Botswana must tackle in a more comprehensive
manner as a matter of priority in order for it to effectively respect and protect the human
rights of minorities – and others – and its international obligations. The desiderata of Vision
2036 of communities freely living, practising and celebrating their diverse cultures,
including their languages, does not seem consistent with the refusal described in the present
report to allow the licensing of community radio stations that could broadcast in minority
languages (see para. 62) or the prohibition of the teaching of a minority language in private
schools (see paras. 32–34). This is a general observation, since in some areas of the
country, such as Ghanzi, the Special Rapporteur sensed that the local administration
acknowledged the importance of local languages and attempted to respond to the needs of
local minority communities by taking into account their different languages and cultures.
3
6
Botho has been described as a philosophy that promotes the common good of society and includes
humanness as an essential element of human growth.