A/HRC/40/64/Add.2
effective policy monitoring and evaluation systems, makes reference to targeting
“vulnerable members of society” and “vulnerable and disadvantaged groups”.
55.
The Special Rapporteur appreciates the work and commitment of civil society in this
area and welcomes the development of partnerships between civil society, the Government
and the private sector in taking this forward. He encourages the Government to continue
and expand its community-based approach and to further develop capacity in the tourism
industry, particularly focusing on those minorities who are among the country’s most
vulnerable and disadvantaged.
56.
At the same time however, the Special Rapporteur learned of minority communities
in Kasane, as well as communities located within the Chobe National Park and forest
reserves, who felt poorly served in terms of the implementation of policies and programmes
that should normally ensure their equal access to State services, such as education and
health care. Chobe is the country’s only district without a senior secondary school. Some
children from Chobe therefore are sent to live 300 kilometres away in Nata to attend school
or are even sent to live in hostels as far away as Francistown or Maun, 500 and even 600
kilometres away, almost completely isolated from their families, cultures and homes for
most of the year. With regard to land tenure, minority communities such as the Basubiya
have limited access to the lease of very small plots of land, since their traditional lands are
considered to be State land. While damage done to their crops, homes, property and even to
themselves means in theory that they are entitled to some compensation, the amounts
involved are often either insignificant or at times not paid when the budget for
compensation has been exhausted. The inhabitants of Kavimba, Mabele and neighbouring
Basubiya villages even face the challenge of being locked in after 6.30 or 7.30 p.m. every
evening, when the road leading from their communities to Kasane, which is outside the
national park and where most government and other services are located, is closed except
for emergency medical evacuations. These issues also give rise to the feeling often
expressed among the non-Tswana minorities who live in these communities that they are
not fairly treated by the State.
57.
While inadequate access to water occurred in urban poor areas as well as rural poor
areas, it was pointed out to the Special Rapporteur that such difficulties seemed to
disproportionally affect settlements where certain nomadic and minority communities lived,
including in particular San and other Basarwa communities. The Special Rapporteur was
told of settlements with more than the 250 persons required to become a recognized
settlement for the provision of basic services that still had no water connection. He was also
informed that even in a major town such as Maun, with a concentration of Wayeyi and
other minorities, provision of water in the municipality was not always guaranteed,
sometimes for many days. People did not always know why the Water Utilities Corporation
was sometimes unable to supply water through its pipelines. In more remote settlements,
where water tanks were to be supplied on a regular basis, the Special Rapporteur was told
that the provision of water was not always systematic and that public water tanks could
occasionally be empty for four to five consecutive days. He was also informed, for
example, that water in Gaborone was provided by the North-East District where rainfall
rates were among the highest in the country, and yet localities in the same District close to a
water dam did not have access to that water because there was no infrastructure available to
pump and distribute the water to those localities.
58.
In most of the meetings outside of Gaborone, the issue of land or resource use,
including water use, was a recurring theme. At times this was due to frustrations at the
complexity of the existing legal framework and procedures to be followed or because of the
lack of available information, including in the languages of minority communities. On other
occasions it seemed that existing policies and programmes were simply not implemented as
expected or announced. At the very least information campaigns are needed to more fully
educate the general public, particularly minority communities outside the Gaborone region
who feel left out and suspicious of State actions, which are too often assumed to privilege
the Tswana.
12