E/CN.4/1999/58/Add.1
page 26
with problematical situations, which are described as exceptions, involving
hate crimes, the Supreme Court's decision in the Smith case and religion at
the workplace, the community is displaying real vigour both through the
dialogue between religions and through a militancy in making claims and
seeking to promote greater awareness in the field of religion.
The Muslim community
76.
The situation of Muslims is distinctly less favourable, although taken
all in all it is not negative. The Muslim community can certainly flourish
freely in the religious sphere, but it has to be recognized that there is an
islamophobia reflecting both racial and religious intolerance. This is not
the fault of the authorities, but of very harmful activity by the media in
general and the popular press in particular, which consists in putting out a
distorted and indeed hate-filled message treating Muslims as extremists and
terrorists. American public opinion - and hence society - is thus informed and formed - by negative representations of the Muslims. The Special
Rapporteur raises the question of the responsibility of the media for
manifestations - direct or indirect, intentional or not - of racial and
religious intolerance and discrimination in society, on the part of citizens,
but also of officials acting on their own initiative and of private
corporations, manifestations which may be marginal, but nevertheless do really
affect Muslims. It is up to the public authorities to help combat the
iniquitous representation of Muslims. Here the Special Rapporteur would like
to acknowledge the initiatives taken by President Clinton and his Government
directly or indirectly for the benefit of Muslims and aimed at the development
of strategies for preventing intolerance and discrimination based on religion.
Efforts to combat the ignorance and intolerance purveyed by the media, above
all through preventive measures in the field of education, should be given
priority. The interdenominational dialogue practised in certain States,
particularly California, as was evident at the time of the Gulf war, can also
serve as an example to the international community. The activities of the
Interreligious Council of Southern California deserve to be better known and
should be taken as a model.
Other communities in the field of religion or belief
77.
The situation of Asian religions (Buddhism, Hinduism, etc.) and
“marginal” religions (Jehovah's Witnesses, Mormons outside Utah, Seventh-Day
Adventists, Assembly of God, etc.) is generally satisfactory. There are of
course exceptions, such as cases of discrimination at the workplace, and
obstacles relating to places of worship and attacks on them. These obstacles
and acts of discrimination are sometimes the consequences of the Smith case
and a form of secularism, as explained in the section on the constitutional
clauses. They can also be interpreted in a general way as manifestations of a
conflict between intense religion and unintense religion. In accordance with
this interpretation, it appears finally that in general the position of
minority communities in the sphere of religion or belief corresponds to that
of the majority Christian communities, with the proviso that any difficulties
encountered by the latter are less acute precisely because of their majority
status.