A/70/335
respondent, who should also have the option of indicating multiple or no ethnic
affiliations without any negative consequences. Some of the identified shortcomings
of self-identification include the discrepancy between self-perception and
perception by others, as that may not reflect the fact that racism and discrimination
are often based on appearance rather than identity. 14 It has been pointed out that,
although several studies have concluded that the outcomes of classification by third
parties and self-classification are relatively similar, distrust may lead to
underreporting by members of certain communities, who would prefer not to be
classified among those groups which are subject to discriminatory attitudes. The
Special Rapporteur believes that, despite those shortcomings, self -identification
should remain the norm, as it is based on the important notion that the State should
not impose an identity on the individual.
58. The Special Rapporteur stresses that confidence-building efforts are needed in
order to persuade minorities that there is nothing to fear from self -identifying with a
group. That is important for the successful conduct of personal data collection
exercises, in terms of both the quantity and accuracy of the inf ormation gathered.
3.
Participation
59. Self-identification also implies the participation of target populations in the
data collection process. The human rights principle of participation encourages all
sections of the population, including vulnerable and marginalized groups and human
rights and other relevant institutions, to actively contribute to the decision -making
process surrounding the collection of data.
60. The Special Rapporteur believes that indicators should be relevant to the
communities surveyed and that the active involvement of targeted groups would
enable such relevance. Consulting all stakeholders in all stages of the exercise
would help to build confidence between the authorities and the groups concerned
and would also lead to better survey design, including the choice of relevant
indicators. Moreover, involvement should also be understood as providing the right
to members of vulnerable groups to be informed about the results of data collection
and about the effectiveness of the anti-discrimination legislation, policies and
programmes in place.
V. Implementing equality data collection and disaggregation
A.
Institutional and policy framework
61. The Special Rapporteur would like to stress the importance of establishing
adequate mechanisms and an institutional framework for the collection of personal
data, in strict compliance with the necessary human rights safeguards. The different
stakeholders, including national statistical agencies, relevant government agencies,
national human rights institutions and civil society organizations, should come
together in measuring discrimination and also in monitoring and assessing the
impact of adjustment policies.
62. According to the Principles and Recommendations for Population and
Housing Censuses, censuses are the principal means of collecting basic population
statistics, as they provide a comprehensive source of statistical information for
15-14106
17/24